We have a similar archive for D3football.com's front page polls, so I wanted to create one for D3hoops.com.
Which men's team should be ranked No. 1 to start the season?
Augustana (181) 21%
Whitman (170) 20%
Babson (95) 11%
Williams (92) 11%
Someone else (308) 36%
Total votes: 1141
Which newly ranked team will stay in the poll the longest?
UW-Oshkosh men (105) 24%
Bowdoin women (104) 24%
Whitworth men (90) 21%
Ohio Wesleyan men (69) 16%
Messiah women (40) 9%
Muhlenberg women (27) 6%
Total votes: 435
Which team is the biggest surprise of the season so far?
York (Pa.) men (82) 28%
New Jersey City men (61) 21%
Wittenberg men (57) 20%
Marietta women (41) 14%
Juniata women (40) 14%
Washington & Jefferson women (10) 3%
Total votes: 291
Who should be the new No. 1 in the women's Top 25 poll after Tufts and Christopher Newport both lost?
Amherst (154) 33%
Someone else (112) 24%
Hope (76) 17%
Wartburg (70) 15%
UW-Oshkosh (48) 10%
Total votes: 460
Which rivalry games matter most to the postseason picture this year?
Wooster-Wittenberg men (217) 32%
Whitewater-Stevens Point men (213) 31%
Amherst-Williams men (139) 21%
Hope-Calvin women (109) 16%
Total votes: 678
Which of these four teams has the best chance to finish a perfect season?
Amherst women (183) 38%
Whitman men (161) 33%
Wittenberg men (86) 18%
Wartburg women (44) 9%
Total votes: 474
Missed posting this.
Which of the five men's first-place teams has the best shot to win the NESCAC tournament?
Williams (229) 30%
Amherst (190) 25%
Wesleyan (132) 17%
Hamilton (115) 15%
Middlebury (94) 12%
Total votes: 760
Which men's team that was left out most deserved a bid?
Amherst (619) 31%
None of these teams deserved to get in (525) 26%
Ohio Northern (353) 17%
Hobart (352) 17%
East Texas Baptist (119) 6%
Total votes: 1968
Which was the biggest first-round upset of the past 10 years?
Aurora over Wash U, 2018 (180) 39%
Defiance over UW-Whitewater, 2015 (68) 14%
Bethany Lutheran over St. John's, 2018 (62) 13%
Northwestern over St. Thomas, 2015 (40) 8%
Albertus Magnus over William Paterson, 2010 (21) 4%
Wartburg over Benedictine, 2017 (20) 4%
Wisconsin Lutheran over Wheaton, 2015 (20) 4%
Gwynedd Mercy over Marietta, 2016 (16) 3%
Smith over Southern Maine, 2013 (15) 3%
Trinity (Texas) over UMHB, 2012 (15) 3%
Total votes: 457
Which women's host is most likely to advance?
Amherst (179) 49%
Hope (80) 22%
Wartburg (74) 20%
Scranton (27) 7%
Total votes: 360
How many games will St. Joseph (Conn.) win in its first year, with Jim Calhoun at the helm?
11-15 (305) 31%
6-10 (221) 23%
15-20 (203) 21%
20 or more (139) 14%
Five or fewer (114) 12%
Total votes: 982
Now that Amherst lost, who should be the new No. 1 in women's basketball?
Someone else (252) 33%
Bowdoin (228) 30%
St. Thomas (111) 15%
Hope (99) 13%
Chicago (72) 9%
Total votes: 762
Guess we should've included Thomas More as an option. They ended up beating two of the teams on this list.
Folks -- this is an archive, not a discussion. Non-archive posts will continue to be removed. Thanks.
Which team has been the biggest surprise?
Wabash men (81) 35%
St. Thomas men (51) 22%
Capital men (33) 14%
UW-La Crosse women (32) 14%
DeSales women (22) 9%
Mary Hardin-Baylor women (9) 3%
Total votes: 228
Who should be the No. 1 men's team?
Augustana (171) 35%
UW-Oshkosh (137) 28%
Nebraska Wesleyan (108) 22%
Whitman (70) 14%
Total votes: 386