Menu

Show posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Show posts Menu

Messages - Bob.Gregg

#1
W&J lost two touchdowns, fumbling the ball into the endzone.
Since losing to Grove City (and the shot at the PAC title), lack of crispness had been a struggle.
Too many Unsportsmanlike penalties (like yesterday, like CMU), too many dropped passes, too many missed tackles.
#2
2022 W&J beat Hobart in a non-conference game. (after regular season)
2022 W&J beat John Carroll in a non-conference game.

2022 CMU beat Whitworth in a non-conference game.
2022 CMU beat RPI in a non-conference game.

2022 Grove City beat FDU-Florham in a non-conference game. (after regular season)

W&J, CWRU & CMU are all in same boat.  Need to win out, convincingly wouldn't hurt, hope for a little out-of-conference chaos, and force the committee to leave out a 9-1 team.

#3
Quote from: E.115 on August 02, 2023, 04:03:21 PM

Btw are there any other PAC posters not from CWRU ??

Yes
#4
ECAC website story repeatedly refers to WILLIAM & Jefferson....
You'd think the third-winningest team (771 wins) in NCAA Division III would not be misidentified...

https://ecacsports.com/news/2022/11/19/football-presidents-pick-up-bushnell-bowl-victory-over-statesmen.aspx
#5
Utica had to be ahead of Hopkins when time came to choose the at-large teams.
Final regional rankings flipped or national committee flipped final regional rankings.
If I wanted to, I'd look at who is on what committee...
#6
Unless Westminster knocks off Case-Western Reserve next weekend, the winner of the Nov. 12 Academic Bowl takes the PAC AQ.

IF the Titans win next week, the would clinch the PAC title for Carnegie-Mellon.
#7
The PAC AQ is going to go to one of these five four three two (no big surprise):

CMU      6-0
CWRU   4-1 (loss to Grove)

Grove   4-2 (loss to CMU, West)
W&J      3-2 (loss to CWRU, CMU)
West      3-2 (loss to CMU, W&J)

Here are Big 5 head-to-head results so far:
Carnegie-Mellon 40, Grove City 33
Carnegie-Mellon 10, Westminster 0
Carnegie-Mellon 12, Wash-Jeff 7
Case-Western 14, Wash-Jeff 10
Wash-Jeff 17, Westminster 14
Grove City 14, Case-Western 13
Westminster 24, Grove City 17


Here's the remaining schedule of head-to-head matchups (other games involving Big 5):
Oct. 29 none (CMU vs. StVinc, W&J at Thiel, CWRU @ All, West @ Wayne)
Nov. 5 Grove at Wash-Jeff, CWRU at West
Nov. 12 CMU at CWRU (Grove vs. Thiel, W&J @ Way, West @ Gen)


IF CMU wins out, the AQ goes to the Tartans.
IF Case-Western wins out, the AQ goes to the Spartans.

Grove City, W&J and Westminster all need CMU to lose twice and CWRU to lose once.

#8
I've seen, in person or on video, each of the Big 5.
Nobody has an offense that can compete even in the first round at the national level.

And, if the PAC champion/AQ doesn't get a real favorable match-up, will likely get blown out.
The Big 5's defensive numbers are against really lacking offenses for the most part.

Just my view from the 34 yard line.
#9
I'm off on my Bye week. I'll update this sometime on Sunday when I get the chance.
I'm voting for complete and total chaos the rest of the way (W&J's only real hope now).


The PAC AQ is going to go to one of these five four three (no big surprise):

CMU      5-0
Grove   4-1 (loss to CMU)
CWRU   3-1 (loss to Grove)

W&J      3-2 (loss to CWRU, CMU)
West      2-2 (loss to CMU)


Here are head-to-head results so far:

Carnegie-Mellon 40, Grove City 33
Carnegie-Mellon 10, Westminster 0
Carnegie-Mellon 12, Wash-Jeff 7
Case-Western 14, Wash-Jeff 10
Wash-Jeff 17, Westminster 14
Grove City 14, Case-Western 13


Here's the remaining schedule of head-to-head matchups:

Oct. 22 West at Grove (CMU vs. Gen, CWRU vs. Beth)
Oct. 29 none (CMU vs. StVinc, W&J at Thiel, CWRU @ All, West @ Wayne)
Nov. 5 Grove at Wash-Jeff, CWRU at West
Nov. 12 CMU at CWRU (Grove vs. Thiel, W&J @ Way, West @ Gen)


IF CMU wins out, the AQ goes to the Tartans.
IF Grove City wins out, the Wolverines need somebody to beat CMU.
IF Case-Western wins out, the Spartans need somebody to beat Grove City.
IF Wash-Jeff wins out, the Presidents need somebody to beat CWRU & CMU.
IF Westminster wins out, the Titans need somebody to beat CMU & W&J.
#10
Just got this word:

Cole Konieczka's career has concluded.

"Cole broke his ankle, and his career is over," lamented Titans' taskmaster Scott Benzel, who added, "My heart breaks for him."

Konieczka (Coraopolis, Pa./Moon Area High) sustained the injury last week against Washington & Jefferson. Scrambling for a first down, he slid awkwardly and did not return. Initially it was believed he had sustained a high-ankle sprain.
#11
The PAC AQ is going to go to one of these five four (no big surprise):
Carnegie-Mellon 4-0
Grove City 3-1
Wash-Jeff 3-1
CaseWestern 3-1
Westminster 1-2

Here are head-to-head results so far:
Carnegie-Mellon 40, Grove City 33
Carnegie-Mellon 10, Westminster 0
Grove City 14, Case-Western 13
Case-Western 14, Wash-Jeff 10
Wash-Jeff 17, Westminster 14

Here's the remaining schedule of head-to-head matchups:
Oct. 15 Carnegie-Mellon at Wash-Jeff
Oct. 22 Westminster at Grove City
Oct. 29 none
Nov. 5 Grove City at Wash-Jeff, Case-Western at Westminster
Nov. 12 Carnegie-Mellon at Case-Western

IF CMU wins out, the AQ goes to the Tartans.
IF Wash-Jeff wins out, the Presidents need somebody to beat CWRU.
IF Grove City wins out, the Wolverines need somebody to beat CMU.
IF Case-Western wins out, the Spartans need somebody to beat Grove City.
IF Westminster wins out, the Titans need somebody to beat CMU plus a lot of other help.
#12
The PAC AQ is going to go to one of these five (no big surprise):
Carnegie-Mellon 3-0
Grove City 2-1
Wash-Jeff 2-1
CaseWestern 2-1
Westminster 1-1

Here are head-to-head results so far:
Carnegie-Mellon 40, Grove City 33
Carnegie-Mellon 10, Westminster 0
Grove City 14, Case-Western 13
Case-Western 14, Wash-Jeff 10

Here's the remaining schedule of head-to-head matchups:
Oct. 8  Wash-Jeff at Westminster
Oct. 15 Carnegie-Mellon at Wash-Jeff
Oct. 22 Westminster at Grove City
Oct. 29 none
Nov. 5 Grove City at Wash-Jeff, Case-Western at Westminster
Nov. 12 Carnegie-Mellon at Case-Western

IF CMU wins out, the AQ goes to the Tartans.
IF Wash-Jeff wins out, the Presidents need somebody to beat CWRU.
IF Grove City wins out, the Wolverines need somebody to beat CMU.
IF Westminster wins out, the Titans need somebody to beat CMU
IF Case-Western wins out, the Spartans need somebody to beat Grove City.
#13
CMU manages just 8 first downs and wins the game, 10-0.
Tartans alone atop the PAC standings.

W&J heading to New Wilmington next Saturday in an elimination game.
#14
Week 5 already.....3 conference unbeatens, 3 conference winless, 5 conference 1-1 teams...

Allegheny (1-1) at Wash/Jeff (1-1)
Case-Western (2-0) at Grove City (1-1)
Thiel (0-1) at Bethany (0-1)
Westminster (1-0) at Carnegie-Mellon (2-0)

Geneva, Saint Vincent and Waynesburg are all on recess this weekend.
#15
In the shot from the W&J/CWRU game, that's John Sacco's right side in the first pressbox window.  If you zoom in, you can see my right arm a little further over in the front window.

As you can see, my seat is approximately the 28 yard line on the scoreboard end.  The play where I mistakenly identified the never-give-up tackler happened at the other end of the field on the W&J sideline.  And the CWRU uniform color scheme and number font didn't help, nor did my now 62 1/2 year old eyes...