Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - Christan Shirk

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 10
1
Men's soccer / Re: 2016 Schedules
« on: May 25, 2016, 01:32:02 pm »
Did USMMA move out of the Landmark? 

Answering my own question here:

USMMA is now in the Skyline.  Not sure if NCAA Tournament eligible for 2016, but they will be a November mainstay out of that conference for the future...

You should check out our website, D3soccer.com, more often  ;)   We mentioned this in our August 20, 2015 article What's new for 2015 season? in the final section "Changes (and Potential Changes) on the Horizon". 

As to your lingering question: they are NCAA eligible this year.  Not really sure why you would have questioned that.  Their status as a D-III member isn't affected in any way by changing conferences or even if they had gone independent.  The conference affiliation would only affect which tournament selection Pool(s) they are in (A/C or B/C).   In this case, the Skyline was already an AQ conference and, obviously, adding another team doesn't do anything to change that, so USMMA will be fighting for the Skylines's AQ berth (Pool A) and, failing that, a Pool C at-large berth.

By the way, there's other changes in conference affiliation happening for the 2016 season (e.g. Carroll moving to the CIIW).  Check out that article from last year and then keep an eye out for a similar article again this year.

2
Well, this was an intersting topic to see here today, especially four days after the current "Reader's Poll" was published. For the record, I wrote the poll; I wrote the options; I take full responsibility.  Part of me wanted to wait until more people gave their perspectives on our poll (and specifically the options provided) before posting a response here, because I am genuinely curious if Mr. Right's take is representative of many others. But I won't delay.  And even though part of me would prefer to just post a big ol' "Lighten up! It was a joke!", I'm going to basically post here what I wrote in response to the few e-mails we received shortly after the poll was published on Sunday (e-mails, which I might add, though "concerned" about the absence of the "NESCAC" as an option, acknowledged the possibility of an honest oversight/clerical error--a granting of the benefit of the doubt that was appreciated).

Given the NESCAC had just claimed both men's and women's titles (something I assumed everyone reading and responding to the poll would know), the poll was somewhat of a rhetorical, toungue-in-cheek joke (not that a case couldn't be made for the UAA--actually a very strong case, and maybe another conference or two). I wanted to have fun with it as I have sometimes done in the past with our poll questions. But apparently what I intended to be funny (the blatant omission of the most glarringly obvious answer) hasn't translated for everyone even though I tried to make it rather obvious by placing the "other" option right where the NESCAC should have been listed instead of placing the "other" option at the very end of the list as is normal. I thought that would assure everyone would "get it" . . . if not right away, as least after a few seconds. 

My other option was to post the same poll question, but repeatedly list the NESCAC as option one, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight, and nine, with the obligatory "other" as option ten.  I opted for the more subtle, might-take-a-second-or-two-to-get approach knowing it might put a rise into some NESCAC fans until they got the joke (not if they got the joke). I miscalculated, apparently, whether that is due more to over-estimating my ability to execute the intended joke or under-estimating how seriously NESCAC fans take this stuff and wouldn't be able to find the humor in it, I don't know.

Bottom line, the honest truth is that the poll was/is meant as a light, humorous tip of the cap to the NESCAC, not an unintended oversight nor an intentional slight (neither of which would have been consistent with the website's complete body of work, in my opinion). I hope that most fans have picked up on that and have taken the poll in the sense it was/is intended. If not, it won't be the first nor last time I miss the mark, and I can live with that.

However, what would have the potential to bother me much more would be if the broader sentiments seemingly expressed by Mr. Right were representative of a larger segment of the fans on here and the visitors to our website. I truly hope not and would be surprised and disappointed to find that to be the case. Even if this particular poll didn't/doesn't sit right with some, I would hope that's not reflective of or consistent with a broader perception of the website. But, if it is, I am open to listening to Mr. Right and any others who believe they have reason to think D3soccer.com is guilty of or prone to (i) pettiness, (ii) unappreciativeness of NESCAC fans (or any segment of fans) for visiting/supporting the website, (iii) disrespect of NESCAC fans (or any segment fo fans), and (iv) biases and favoritism shown to certain schools (e.g. Messiah) or conferences. If there are instances or examples of these types of things, please specifically name them so they can be discussed and maybe we can learn and improve moving forward. (And that can be done openly on the message board or privately via e-mail.)

The Final Top 25 and All-America teams will be coming.  No promises on time-table.

3
Men's soccer / Re: 2015 D3 Season: NATIONAL PERSPECTIVE
« on: December 09, 2015, 03:02:42 pm »
All:

Without naming names and getting into details, reasons, excuses, forgetfulness, etc. that may or may not be self-incriminating, there will be a final D3soccer.com Top 25 poll.  It will be late.  Hopefully Friday.

4
Men's soccer / Re: 2015 NCAA TOURNAMENT THREAD
« on: December 03, 2015, 08:22:47 am »
D3soccer.com's fourth and final coach's interview has been published.

December 3, 2015
Interview: Iain Byrne, Oneonta State men's coach
The 13th-year head coach of the Oneonta State Red Dragons talks to D3soccer.com
about how he's built the program, his team's great defense and exciting style of play,
and the drive to go one step further than 2014.

By Ryan Harmanis

5
Men's soccer / Re: 2015 NCAA TOURNAMENT THREAD
« on: December 02, 2015, 03:06:37 pm »
D3soccer.com's third coach's interview has been published.

December 2, 2015
Interview: Ryan Souders, Calvin men's coach
The 4th-year head coach of the Calvin Knights talks to D3soccer.com about
his team's difficult run through the tournament, their incredible team culture, and
their malleable playing style heading into this weekend.

By Ryan Harmanis

6
Men's soccer / Re: 2015 NCAA TOURNAMENT THREAD
« on: December 01, 2015, 04:19:44 pm »
Just a little "inside baseball" talk here...the way it's listed on their men's soccer schedule has nothing to do with Amherst and everything to do with PrestoSports, their content management system. When you go to schedule a game in Presto, it has all possible opponents listed in their system, and you have to select what they have it labeled as. In this case, it appears Presto themselves haven't made the switch from Oneonta State to SUNY Oneonta. If you look elsewhere on Amherst's men's soccer page, like in the preview they posted for example, they use the SUNY Oneonta terminology.

That's true, however, each website using PrestoSports is able to customize any school name specifically for their website. That said, I don't expect an SID or his/her staff to take the time to utilize this customization feature. We at D3soccer.com have numerous customized names (most from before I was involved) where someone decided to deviate from what the larger network uses. And I know we could customize numerous others to get to a/the more commonly used variation of a school's name (changing Rochester Tech to RIT is on my list for next season as that has been annoying me for years). One reason we would hesitate to make a change is that it creates issues with the archives and naviagting into/through archived previous seasons unless you take a fair amount of time to update the name in numerous locations/files for each archived season. But this is boring for most everyone.  I would be curious to know (and another thread would be the place for it) what names we us on D3soccer.com that our visitors think we should go with another variation.

7
Men's soccer / Re: 2015 NCAA TOURNAMENT THREAD
« on: December 01, 2015, 01:40:42 pm »
D3soccer.com's second coach's interview has been published.

December 1, 2015
Interview: Justin Serpone, Amherst men's coach
The 9th-year head coach of the Amherst Lord Jeffs talks to D3soccer.com about
winnng for the players that came before, his team's playing style, key players and
leaders, and grinding to the Final Four.

By Ryan Harmanis

8
Men's soccer / Re: 2015 NCAA TOURNAMENT THREAD
« on: November 30, 2015, 02:39:44 pm »
D3soccer.com's first coach's interview has been published.

November 30, 2015
Interview: Dan Rothert, Loras men's coach
The 18-year head coach of the Loras Duhawks talks to D3soccer.com about
his team's make-up and playing style, the culture and squad depth he's built
over the years, the use of a sweeper, and winning their first semifinal.

By Ryan Harmanis


9
Men's soccer / Re: NCAA Tournament Interesting Trivia Odds and Ends
« on: November 12, 2015, 11:54:53 am »
A shame no one is adding to this thread.  It would make for a great column on D3soccer.com if enough different tid-bits could be compiled. 

In a slightly different vein, but hopefully not too out of place, here is this year's Tournament Field Factoids on D3soccer.com.  Not sure why I didn't do one last year after doing it in 2013.

10
Men's soccer / Re: 2015 NCAA TOURNAMENT THREAD
« on: November 09, 2015, 03:37:08 pm »
LGOTB, it looks like you got that list from D3soccer.com because that's precisely the info we give for each team on our Tournament Participants pages, but I couldn't find any reference to MACF / Freedom for Lycoming.  Was that a personal typo on your end?

11
Men's soccer / Re: 2015 D3 Season: NATIONAL PERSPECTIVE
« on: November 08, 2015, 07:16:18 pm »
FWIW, we have Part II of our Men's at-large berth analysis and predictions column up on D3soccer.com that includes the color-coded regional rankings table with updated records/win pct., strength of schedules (approximated), and records versus ranked teams.

If you find any errors, please let me know.  We have tried to be 100% accurate, but it is a lot of data to deal with.

We hope and currently expect to have our predictions posted yet tonight.

12
Men's soccer / Re: 2015 POOL C
« on: November 08, 2015, 07:15:50 pm »
FWIW, we have Part II of our Men's at-large berth analysis and predictions column up on D3soccer.com that includes the color-coded regional rankings table with updated records/win pct., strength of schedules (approximated), and records versus ranked teams.

If you find any errors, please let me know.  We have tried to be 100% accurate, but it is a lot of data to deal with.

We hope and currently expect to have our predictions posted yet tonight.

13
Men's soccer / Re: 2015 Great Lakes Region
« on: November 01, 2015, 10:45:55 pm »
FYI: There is a revised Pre-Championships Manual out.  We at D3soccer.com found numerous inaccuracies in the manual, most regarding school's conference affiliation but also things like how the HCAC AQ is awarded.  We contacted the NCAA we out list of suspected error and they issued a revised manual on October 21.  We have the revised version up on our website under the NCAA Tourney drop-down menu.

14
Men's soccer / Re: 2015 Great Lakes Region
« on: November 01, 2015, 07:47:28 pm »
Sometimes it is very difficult to tell who is considered a conference's champion.  And it almost seems like some conferences allow for two teams to call themselves champions in the same year: one a regular season champion, one a tournament champion.  However, for the HCAC, we at D3soccer.com have been under the impression that the conference champion is the highest regular season team.  Look at the program for the 2014 tournament final: http://static.psbin.com/l/o/4tfkq0d9fidloi/14_msoccer_program_2.pdf  Note the list of Annual Conference Champions.  If you look through the archives, that matches with the top regular season finishers, NOT with the tournament winners.  And note occurrences of co-champions as we have again this year (ref. https://www.hanover.edu/athletics/news?article=6078 and http://athletics.rose-hulman.edu/sports/msoc/2015-16/releases/20151031qbywuw). Here's the comparison for the years 2019 - 2013 just to illustrate.

Year     Annual Champion     1st Reg. Season     Tourn. Winner/AQ     
2014EarlhamEarlhamRose-Hulman
2013EarlhamEarlhamRose-Hulman
2012Transy./RHITTransy./RHITTransylvania
2011TransylvaniaTransylvaniaRose-Hulman
2010TransylvaniaTransylvaniaTransylvania
2009Rose-HulmanRose-HulmanTransylvania

We at D3soccer.com certainly try our best to be as accurate as possible and try to do our due diligence on issues like this.  But we are far from infallible and we welcome (encourage, really) your corrections when we have an error.  In this case I think we have it right, but I can't be 100% sure give some conflicting language/terminology used the HCAC).  And we are far from certain about the NEAC, for example.  Is their champion the top regular season team or the tournament winner?  Very hard to tell from their website.

15
Men's soccer / Re: 2015 D3 Season: NATIONAL PERSPECTIVE
« on: November 01, 2015, 11:43:43 am »
One of North Central's results got input wrong.  The women's result against Augustana (L1-2) was input as the men's result instead of the actual result, a 1-0 win.  I have corrected it and the standings should reflect it momentarily. That correction pushes North Central above North Park.

One thing we are unable to do is tie-breakers, so if there's a tie for the final playoff spots, sometimes the wrong team will be listed higher in the standings.

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 10