Since you mentioned Methodist, I think they're the only USA South school that I haven't seen in person in the past 3-4 years. But Fayetteville is a long hike for me, so I've been looking for a good opportunity to see them play closer to home
But that segues into a list worth mentioning. I do try to spread out the teams I see, though geography doesn't make that goal very easy. Yet in recent years, I've seen in person:ACFC:
Dickinson, Franklin & Marshall, Johns Hopkins, UrsinusODAC:
Bridgewater, Emory & Henry, Guilford, Hampden-Sydney, Washington & LeeUSAC:
Averett, Christopher Newport, Ferrum, Greensboro, Maryville, N.C. Wesleyan, Shenandoah
There's a good mix, but looking at the my post on my potential travel destinations for '09, there's only two new teams on there.