I am, of course, horribly biased in this by the fact that I was there, and with a seriously limited number of games to draw from I'm not sure how much my opinion matters anyway, but if I was to pick the best Calvin/Hope Matchup that I can think of, I would pick the game in Fieldhouse during Calvin's 99-2000 championship season.

Time's running out, Winkle has the ball. Foltice and Karsten are both wide open but Winkle decides to take the shot with some Hope guy (I never learned their names, sorry, they were just the enemy...  ) all over him, makes the ugliest trey I have ever seen in my life to send the game into overtime, and then we ride Veenstra for the win in overtime.

I will probably see that shot in my minds eye for the rest of my life. It was beyond ugly, the Hope player might as well have been sharing his jersey, it should never have gone in... but go in it did.

Beautiful.