FB: Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference

Started by admin, August 16, 2005, 05:19:08 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

GoldandBlueBU, DuffMan, Mister36 and 81 Guests are viewing this topic.

OzJohnnie

Man, I'm irritated by the NESCSCACACA fiasco this year.  The committee seems entirely unable to manage playoff selection for the most qualified teams.  Every time they try to avoid responsibility for making this judgment, they create a system that makes it worse.
  

CarollFan

Bethel HC interviewed starting at 44:50.


art76

"What draws people to be friends is that they see the same truth. They share it."
― C. S. Lewis

OzJohnnie

Quote from: OzJohnnie on Yesterday at 08:01:01 PMMan, I'm irritated by the NESCSCACACA fiasco this year.  The committee seems entirely unable to manage playoff selection for the most qualified teams.  Every time they try to avoid responsibility for making this judgment, they create a system that makes it worse.

My issue with this is that D3 is very focused on rewarding participation, so we have the AQ for every conference, regardless of quality.  Fine, I'm fine with that.

But the "at large" selection is meant to acknowledge nationally competitive seasons from highly competitive programs that a single AQ does not capture in the post-season formula.  So they create this pseudo-scientific NPI algorithm that simultaneously removes all discretion (and responsibility) from the selection process and creates an even more politically outrageous result.

The result of this cowardly abstention of judgement is that it expressly undermines the pursuit of excellence by high-achieving programs.  Creating a program of BU's quality is neither cheap nor easy, but we now find the National Committee disregarding the successful results of those expensive labours, all in an effort to avoid responsibility for making sound judgement (and the consequences of unsound judgements). 

It's a disgrace that they, as well as supporters of these results, now stand behind the NPI as some sort of legitimate outcome because it's the rules.  I find myself in the odd position of quoting the wisdom of the psychopathic killer Anton Chigurh in No Country for Old Men: "If the rule you followed brought you to this, of what use was the rule?"
  

CHUBBS PETERSON

I hate this outcome for BU's seniors, in particular.

"Now I'm gonna assume that by now you've learned that the world's not fair and sometimes you get the short end. That's all you get. And if you don't do something personally to fix it, then that's all you're ever gonna get."
-Coach Gaines, Friday Night Lights

Granted, all this is made academic by better on-field results; totally get that. Those on-field results make it pretty obvious that this year's BU team isn't on par with the best in the country, but that doesn't excuse them having to foot the bill for the NCAA's incompetence...and not for the first time in recent history either. Third time in 3 years that Bethel has gotten jammed by the NCAA in some form; getting to be an unwelcomed annual tradition in Arden Hills at this point.

All this could have been prevented if the NCAA stipulated that this bush-league NE conference that's about to go 0-3 in round 1 get workable tiebreak procedures in order just like everybody else as a condition for member schools being playoff eligible. But no, the NCAA proves to be as useful as a screen door on a submarine as it so often does.

Happy Thanksgiving to all, and here's hoping the SJU contingent has fun storming the castle.
Bethel Royals on to victory as we proudly sing your name, HEY HEY HEY!

hazzben

I'm actually not convinced the cake eaters from the NESCAC won't win a few games in their pillow fight of a quadrant. Which people will regard as evidence they were right to have all 3 in the field.

CHUBBS PETERSON

May well be the case, and would be further evidence of just how regionally condensed D3 football is becoming.
Bethel Royals on to victory as we proudly sing your name, HEY HEY HEY!

DuffMan

Greg made the point on today's podcast that even with the previous system, Bethel would have very much been a bubble team at 8-2. 0-2 vs. regionally ranked teams. It's definitely an imperfect system, but it is what we've got.

A tradition unrivaled...
MIAC Champions: '32, '35, '36, '38, '53, '62, '63, '65, '71, '74, '75, '76, '77, '79, '82, '85, '89, '91, '93, '94, '95, '96, '98, '99, '01, '02, '03, '05, '06, '08, '09, '14, '18, '19, '21, '22, '24, '26
National Champions: '63, '65, '76, '03

art76

#111428
Quote from: DuffMan on Today at 10:54:36 AMGreg made the point on today's podcast that even with the previous system, Bethel would have very much been a bubble team at 8-2. 0-2 vs. regionally ranked teams. It's definitely an imperfect system, but it is what we've got.

I heard the same discussion - good podcast this morning.

Will continue to bite my tongue as many have already expressed my frustrations. I am hopeful that tweaks get made to better make the final 40 (or 48) to actually include the best teams that year.

I do not completely understand the current system math, so I cannot truly comment on what "dials to adjust". But a rule change or two that could help limit the number of "at large" bids a conference can have, might be in order. Off the cuff, every AQ conference gets no more than one at large bid. While this "equalizes" or "spreads out" the at large teams, it certainly does not guarantee to get the better teams in the playoffs.

Something else to entertain is to limit the number of AQs, by making the minimum number of teams in a conference go up to 7 or 8, or making a minimum loss cut-off line of 3 losses a year for any conference champion. This year a rule of that nature would automatically eliminate the UMAC from this year's playoffs. They can still have their conference champions, but then to award them a playoff spot where they stand almost no chance to win a game against anyone else in the tournament is just cruel and humiliating, both for them, and the potential teams that stand better chances of winning games in the tourney.

Edit: After posting I realized I left out a condition of those three loss AQs - only if they played 10 D3 games that season. If they played less than a full slate, the number of minimum losses goes down to 2. This totally encourages teams to go after D3 teams to fill out their schedules.

Trying to balance it all, is a tall order for the play-off committee. Here's hoping they make meaningful changes in the off-season.
"What draws people to be friends is that they see the same truth. They share it."
― C. S. Lewis

OzJohnnie

Quote from: DuffMan on Today at 10:54:36 AMGreg made the point on today's podcast that even with the previous system, Bethel would have very much been a bubble team at 8-2. 0-2 vs. regionally ranked teams. It's definitely an imperfect system, but it is what we've got.

True, but the reason we have this system is because the previous system didn't work.
  

CHUBBS PETERSON

Quote from: DuffMan on Today at 10:54:36 AMGreg made the point on today's podcast that even with the previous system, Bethel would have very much been a bubble team at 8-2. 0-2 vs. regionally ranked teams. It's definitely an imperfect system, but it is what we've got.
Obviously the context in which he said this matters, but it appears he made the opposite point of the one he intended.

The NPI formula needed to be open source and implying that strength of schedule will matter when it really didn't is ethically dubious, at best. No team in their right mind with playoff ambitions is going to schedule a fellow national blue chip program for their non-conference game when strength of opponent is valued so lightly. Clearly, that juice aint worth the squeeze.
Bethel Royals on to victory as we proudly sing your name, HEY HEY HEY!

DuffMan

The NPI formula for '26 didn't change from '25. I applaud Bethel for scheduling NCC, but they knew the potential repurcussions of it.

To be clear, I'm not saying that I am in favor of the current formula (or "dials"), but at least it is transparent.

A tradition unrivaled...
MIAC Champions: '32, '35, '36, '38, '53, '62, '63, '65, '71, '74, '75, '76, '77, '79, '82, '85, '89, '91, '93, '94, '95, '96, '98, '99, '01, '02, '03, '05, '06, '08, '09, '14, '18, '19, '21, '22, '24, '26
National Champions: '63, '65, '76, '03

Patrick Coleman

Quote from: DuffMan on Today at 03:06:46 PMThe NPI formula for '26 didn't change from '25. I applaud Bethel for scheduling NCC, but they knew the potential repurcussions of it.

To be clear, I'm not saying that I am in favor of the current formula (or "dials"), but at least it is transparent.

True, although the number of at-large bids did change in April when the SCAC found a way to an automatic bid.
https://d3football.com/notables/2026/04/gallaudet-lands-in-scac
Publisher. Questions? Check our FAQ for D3f, D3h.
Quote from: old 40 on September 25, 2007, 08:23:57 PMLet's discuss (sports) in a positive way, sometimes kidding each other with no disrespect.

DuffMan


A tradition unrivaled...
MIAC Champions: '32, '35, '36, '38, '53, '62, '63, '65, '71, '74, '75, '76, '77, '79, '82, '85, '89, '91, '93, '94, '95, '96, '98, '99, '01, '02, '03, '05, '06, '08, '09, '14, '18, '19, '21, '22, '24, '26
National Champions: '63, '65, '76, '03

GoldandBlueBU

Quote from: DuffMan on Today at 03:06:46 PMThe NPI formula for '26 didn't change from '25. I applaud Bethel for scheduling NCC, but they knew the potential repurcussions of it.

To be clear, I'm not saying that I am in favor of the current formula (or "dials"), but at least it is transparent.

Yeah - that is where I am it...they knew the risks, and I'm still glad they elected to push the program / team.  I do wish that the system encouraged scheduling this sort of game, rather than incentivized picking up a blowout.

Tough way to end their career for the seniors.

Go get 'em SJU!  :-\