FB: New England Small College Athletic Conference

Started by admin, August 16, 2005, 04:58:09 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Machiavelli, NescacOutsider, Bantam4life, NescacFam, Airisbeastmango, UfanBill and 35 Guests are viewing this topic.

Who wins the 48th Bates-Hamilton Game?

Bates
2 (18.2%)
Hamilton
9 (81.8%)

Total Members Voted: 11

Voting closed: November 13, 2026, 01:54:54 PM

Trin9-0

Like I've said all along... a random draw was the BEST and most sensible way to break a three-way tie...  ;)

In all seriousness this turned out to be much ado about nothing as we've known for weeks if all three NESCAC schools finished 8-1 they were overwhelmingly likely to all get bids. Wesleyan, without the AQ, gets the first round bye based on their NPI. While I have serious misgivings about NPI, this outcome does seem fair given Wes needed to play both Amherst and Trinity on the road.

Congrats to Wesleyan; a threepeat is hugely impressive in this league. Since the NESCAC was officially formed in 1971 this is only the fifth time a program has finished with the best record in the conference three seasons in a row:

Williams - 1988, 1989+, 1990+
Trinity - 2002*, 2003+, 2004+, 2005+
Amherst - 2013*, 2014+, 2015+
Trinity - 2016+, 2017, 2018
Wesleyan - 2024, 2025*, 2026*

*shared title, +undefeated season

I can't recall a worse weekend for SP+ who went 1-4 to finish at still respectable 35-10 on the season. We've all seen the NPI ratings which secured two NESCAC at-large spots in the NCAA field. I wasn't prepared for the online vitriol against the NESCAC but I have to say, I get it. There are some very high quality teams sitting home on Saturday. NPI is far too basic of a model to accurately determine the best teams and without any non-conference data to support our belonging it's obvious that the pitchforks would come for the NESCAC. Hopefully we can put up a good showing over the next few weeks to prove we belong.

Wesleyan gets the final first round bye which is nice but they miss out on a guaranteed home game at Andrus which would have been special. There's still a chance of course that they'll get a home game but they'll need to beat Springfield and hope either Trin or RPI can knock off Endicott on the road. Amherst gets easily the more favorable of the two opening round match-ups. I think they will absolutely roll Bridgewater State. I've seen a couple of MSCAC games as my nephew played for a team in that league and by my estimation, it's not great football. Nescacman, if you do make a return trip to The Coop on Saturday let me know and hopefully we can grab that beer and you can enjoy your well-deserved gloating. Trinity actually has some history with the Engineers; they've met 11 times from 1939-1975 (playing annually from from 1969-'75). The Bantams lead the all-time series 8-2-1.

Here's the final regular season ratings:

SP+              Hansen        NPI
Trinity        345226
Wesleyan        384824
Amherst        997127
Middlebury        10991135
Williams        11394113
Tufts        1238888
Hamilton        14095167
Colby        172125200
Bowdoin        181140238
Bates        204151224

Our little league's first foray into non-conference play since 1991 is throwing the computers for a loop! Look at the discrepancy between the projected scores for Amherst and Bridgewater State! They're split on the Trinity-RPI game as well, although not nearly to the same degree. My opinion is that the Hansen model is generally a bit more accurate which doesn't bode well for my dreams of a Trinity-Wesleyan rematch in the postseason. But, like everyone else in the country I'm excited to see how the NESCAC holds up!

Here's how the computers project the NESCAC teams to fare in the First Round of the NCAA Tournament:

Bridgewater State 22.5 @ Amherst 20.6 - SP+
Bridgewater State 10.9 @ Amherst 34.6 - Hansen

RPI 19.4 @ Trinity 28.6 - SP+
RPI 23.7 @ Trinity 19.6 - Hansen
NESCAC CHAMPS: 1978, 1980, 1983, 1987, 1991, 1993, 1996, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2008, 2012, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2022, 2023, 2025, 2026
UNDEFEATED SEASONS: 1911, 1915, 1934, 1949, 1954, 1955, 1993, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2008, 2012, 2016, 2022

Nescacman

Quote from: Patrick Coleman on Today at 09:51:56 AM
Quote from: Nescacman on Yesterday at 09:09:29 PMSeveral solutions (if solutions are even needed):

1. NESCAC plays an out of league game (like we used to do back in the day). Either play a 10th game or stay at 9 and only play 8 conference games and one out of conference. Either way, we'd add a mid-season bye.
2. Expand the field to 48 teams adding 8 more at-large teams and eliminate the first round, play-in games. That would mean that there are 19 at-large spots instead of 11.
3. Increase the minimum number of teams in your league to get an AQ or only allow teams to receive their AQ if they have 2 or fewer losses.
4. Tweak the NPI formula.
5. Win your games, stop whining, and leave as is.

NM

Eliminating the byes would mean going to 64 teams, not 48, for what it's worth.

You are correct sir. Realized that after my hangover cleared.

Nescacman

Quote from: Trin9-0 on Today at 11:51:23 AMLike I've said all along... a random draw was the BEST and most sensible way to break a three-way tie...  ;)

In all seriousness this turned out to be much ado about nothing as we've known for weeks if all three NESCAC schools finished 8-1 they were overwhelmingly likely to all get bids. Wesleyan, without the AQ, gets the first round bye based on their NPI. While I have serious misgivings about NPI, this outcome does seem fair given Wes needed to play both Amherst and Trinity on the road.

Congrats to Wesleyan; a threepeat is hugely impressive in this league. Since the NESCAC was officially formed in 1971 this is only the fifth time a program has finished with the best record in the conference three seasons in a row:

Williams - 1988, 1989+, 1990+
Trinity - 2002*, 2003+, 2004+, 2005+
Amherst - 2013*, 2014+, 2015+
Trinity - 2016+, 2017, 2018
Wesleyan - 2024, 2025*, 2026*

*shared title, +undefeated season

I can't recall a worse weekend for SP+ who went 1-4 to finish at still respectable 35-10 on the season. We've all seen the NPI ratings which secured two NESCAC at-large spots in the NCAA field. I wasn't prepared for the online vitriol against the NESCAC but I have to say, I get it. There are some very high quality teams sitting home on Saturday. NPI is far too basic of a model to accurately determine the best teams and without any non-conference data to support our belonging it's obvious that the pitchforks would come for the NESCAC. Hopefully we can put up a good showing over the next few weeks to prove we belong.

Wesleyan gets the final first round bye which is nice but they miss out on a guaranteed home game at Andrus which would have been special. There's still a chance of course that they'll get a home game but they'll need to beat Springfield and hope either Trin or RPI can knock off Endicott on the road. Amherst gets easily the more favorable of the two opening round match-ups. I think they will absolutely roll Bridgewater State. I've seen a couple of MSCAC games as my nephew played for a team in that league and by my estimation, it's not great football. Nescacman, if you do make a return trip to The Coop on Saturday let me know and hopefully we can grab that beer and you can enjoy your well-deserved gloating. Trinity actually has some history with the Engineers; they've met 11 times from 1939-1975 (playing annually from from 1969-'75). The Bantams lead the all-time series 8-2-1.

Here's the final regular season ratings:

SP+              Hansen        NPI
Trinity        345226
Wesleyan        384824
Amherst        997127
Middlebury        10991135
Williams        11394113
Tufts        1238888
Hamilton        14095167
Colby        172125200
Bowdoin        181140238
Bates        204151224

Our little league's first foray into non-conference play since 1991 is throwing the computers for a loop! Look at the discrepancy between the projected scores for Amherst and Bridgewater State! They're split on the Trinity-RPI game as well, although not nearly to the same degree. My opinion is that the Hansen model is generally a bit more accurate which doesn't bode well for my dreams of a Trinity-Wesleyan rematch in the postseason. But, like everyone else in the country I'm excited to see how the NESCAC holds up!

Here's how the computers project the NESCAC teams to fare in the First Round of the NCAA Tournament:

Bridgewater State 22.5 @ Amherst 20.6 - SP+
Bridgewater State 10.9 @ Amherst 34.6 - Hansen

RPI 19.4 @ Trinity 28.6 - SP+
RPI 23.7 @ Trinity 19.6 - Hansen

First off, see you Saturday in Hartford for that beer and smoke. Reach out to me so we can figure out logistics. We'll have a special guest(s) in tow (no, not Jon Gruden!).

We are gloating on a number of fronts (NESCAC 3-peat, 3rd straight win over Hartford State, celebrating and "pooping" on the Coop, play-off spot, 24th in NPI which got Wes the coveted and much needed bye week). We are, of course, also gloating over beating the computer. We won one for Team Human!

Our detailed Week 10 picks will be out later this week...stay tuned! Be on the lookout for this week's pod as well featuring HCOF Mills, Matt Fitzsimons and Austin Baker from Wes, either the RPI or Bridgewater HCOF and perhaps other special guests (John Cena perhaps???).

OK, back to reviewing our triple option reads.

NM


   

Trin9-0

I'll bring an extra Trinity hat so you can appropriately cheer on the NESCAC representative...

One other note on Wesleyan's run of success in Hartford; with wins now in 2019, 2024, and 2026 the Cardinals have done something we haven't seen in a quarter century. The last time anyone has won at least 3 out of 4 games in The Coop was Williams who won four straight trips to Jessee-Miller Field in 1995, '97, '99, and '01.

The last time anyone beat Trinity three years in a row was Amherst from 2013-2015 with two of those coming at Pratt Field.


Whether the 126th Trinity-Wesleyan games takes place in 3 weeks or in 51 weeks, the Cardinals can make even more history... the last time Wes beat Trinity four times in a row was the during the Red & Black's longest ever streak over Trinity when they won 9 straight from 1937-1948 (this included a 3 year hiatus as Trinity didn't field a team from 1943-1945 during World War II).
NESCAC CHAMPS: 1978, 1980, 1983, 1987, 1991, 1993, 1996, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2008, 2012, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2022, 2023, 2025, 2026
UNDEFEATED SEASONS: 1911, 1915, 1934, 1949, 1954, 1955, 1993, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2008, 2012, 2016, 2022

maineman

I am kind of amazed.  I remember just about when we went to 9 games and going to the NCAAs was only a dream that most of the comments here on our potential in the tournament was one team in and one and done.  It is amazing to get 3 teams in with speculation that all will advance.  Wesleyan will anyway.

Now we need to get the 10th game for the regular season.  I would hate to have to trade off a conference foe to get a non league game.

Trin9-0

Quote from: Tron on Today at 04:10:26 PMI think you're seriously underestimating Springfield here. Saying Wesleyan will win anyway is pretty disrespectful to a program that has consistently proven itself against some of the best teams in Division III football.

Just two seasons ago, Springfield went 12-0 before traveling to Cortland and beating the No. 2-ranked Red Dragons 40-28 in the NCAA tournament. And this wasn't just another ranked opponent. Cortland was the defending national champion. Springfield rushed for 351 yards and six touchdowns, handing Cortland its second loss of the season and advancing to the Elite Eight for the first time since 2000.

And if you think that was a one-time occurrence, Springfield knocked Cortland out of the NCAA tournament AGAIN the following season, winning 21-7. That's two consecutive NCAA tournament victories over one of the most established programs in Division III football.

Springfield is now making its SIXTH consecutive NCAA tournament appearance, has won six straight NEWMAC championships, and has put together 40 consecutive conference victories. This year's team is 9-1, ranked 12th nationally in the NCAA Power Index (NPI), and averages 310 rushing yards per game, the second-best mark in the country.

Wesleyan absolutely deserves credit for winning three consecutive NESCAC championships, but let's put things into perspective. This is its first-ever NCAA tournament appearance. NESCAC programs have only been eligible for NCAA postseason competition starting this season. Springfield, meanwhile, has been competing at this level for years and has already demonstrated that it can go on the road and beat a defending national champion.

Wesleyan could absolutely win. That's why they play the game. But predicting they'll win anyway without acknowledging what Springfield has accomplished is a pretty uninformed take. I'd suggest giving the Pride a little more respect before writing them off.

I think what maineman meant is that Wesleyan has already "advanced" because they've got a first round bye, not that they will easily dispatch Springfield in round two...
NESCAC CHAMPS: 1978, 1980, 1983, 1987, 1991, 1993, 1996, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2008, 2012, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2022, 2023, 2025, 2026
UNDEFEATED SEASONS: 1911, 1915, 1934, 1949, 1954, 1955, 1993, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2008, 2012, 2016, 2022

Patrick Coleman

Quote from: Trin9-0 on Today at 04:21:08 PMI think what maineman meant is that Wesleyan has already "advanced" because they've got a first round bye, not that they will easily dispatch Springfield in round two...

That's how I understood it.
Publisher. Questions? Check our FAQ for D3f, D3h.
Quote from: old 40 on September 25, 2007, 08:23:57 PMLet's discuss (sports) in a positive way, sometimes kidding each other with no disrespect.

Unionpalooza

Question for the NESCAC folks, since it seems at least possible that the NCAA will introduce the D2 rule that you have to play an out-of-conference game to qualify for an at-large bid: what are the odds that's enough to get the NESCAC to greenlight an additional, OOC game?

Nescacman

Quote from: Trin9-0 on Today at 04:21:08 PM
Quote from: Tron on Today at 04:10:26 PMI think you're seriously underestimating Springfield here. Saying Wesleyan will win anyway is pretty disrespectful to a program that has consistently proven itself against some of the best teams in Division III football.

Just two seasons ago, Springfield went 12-0 before traveling to Cortland and beating the No. 2-ranked Red Dragons 40-28 in the NCAA tournament. And this wasn't just another ranked opponent. Cortland was the defending national champion. Springfield rushed for 351 yards and six touchdowns, handing Cortland its second loss of the season and advancing to the Elite Eight for the first time since 2000.

And if you think that was a one-time occurrence, Springfield knocked Cortland out of the NCAA tournament AGAIN the following season, winning 21-7. That's two consecutive NCAA tournament victories over one of the most established programs in Division III football.

Springfield is now making its SIXTH consecutive NCAA tournament appearance, has won six straight NEWMAC championships, and has put together 40 consecutive conference victories. This year's team is 9-1, ranked 12th nationally in the NCAA Power Index (NPI), and averages 310 rushing yards per game, the second-best mark in the country.

Wesleyan absolutely deserves credit for winning three consecutive NESCAC championships, but let's put things into perspective. This is its first-ever NCAA tournament appearance. NESCAC programs have only been eligible for NCAA postseason competition starting this season. Springfield, meanwhile, has been competing at this level for years and has already demonstrated that it can go on the road and beat a defending national champion.

Wesleyan could absolutely win. That's why they play the game. But predicting they'll win anyway without acknowledging what Springfield has accomplished is a pretty uninformed take. I'd suggest giving the Pride a little more respect before writing them off.

I think what maineman meant is that Wesleyan has already "advanced" because they've got a first round bye, not that they will easily dispatch Springfield in round two...

That's how we understood it too...

Former CAC Coach

Quote from: Unionpalooza on Today at 05:28:32 PMQuestion for the NESCAC folks, since it seems at least possible that the NCAA will introduce the D2 rule that you have to play an out-of-conference game to qualify for an at-large bid: what are the odds that's enough to get the NESCAC to greenlight an additional, OOC game?

Don't underestimate the potential resolve of the NESCAC presidents after they told football to 'cool it for the next ten years'...if they get pushed too hard on the issue of 'adding a non-conference game or else lose any chance of at-large bids', I bet a dollar-to-a-donut that they say "okay, only the AQ can go to the playoffs" OR they say 'revert to an unbalanced 8 game league schedule with 1 non-conference game' - which throws multiple consequences of potential NPI & tie-breaker nonsense into the mix.

They don't care that much about football - allowing a team into the playoffs eased the league's potential legal equity burden that they faced - the prospect of adding a game to appease the rest of Division 3 may not rise to the level of 'necessary change' in their (small) minds.