FB: New England Small College Athletic Conference

Started by admin, August 16, 2005, 04:58:09 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

jmh21, Bantam4life and 34 Guests are viewing this topic.

Who wins the 48th Bates-Hamilton Game?

Bates
2 (18.2%)
Hamilton
9 (81.8%)

Total Members Voted: 11

Voting closed: November 13, 2026, 01:54:54 PM

Nescacman

#25530
2026 Week 10 NESCACMAN Picks: NCAA Playoff Edition (page 1 of 2)

Welcome to NESCAC 2026 Week #10, the first week of the 2026 NCAA Division III Football championship Tournament, "in the league where they pay to play."

WE'RE GOING TO THE NCAA PLAYOFFS!

Well, folks, after more than 50 years of NESCAC football operating in its own little universe, the conference has finally entered the real world of NCAA postseason football. And what an entrance! Not one. Not two. But THREE NESCAC teams have been selected to participate in the 2026 NCAA Division III Football Championship Tournament! Hartford State, Amherst, and Wesleyan all finished the regular season 8-1, sharing the 2026 NESCAC Championship. Each defeated one of the other two and lost to the third. When the conference's tiebreaking procedures failed to determine an automatic qualifier, the decision came down to a random draw. And the winner was... HARTFORD STATE!

The Bantams received the NESCAC's first-ever automatic bid. Amherst and Wesleyan earned at-large invitations. And perhaps the biggest surprise? Wesleyan received a first-round bye and will travel to Springfield College to play in the second round of the tournament on November 28. Wesleyan is the first NESCAC team in history to qualify for the 2nd round of the NCAA play-offs.

For a conference that has spent decades watching the NCAA playoffs from the sidelines, this is an extraordinary development. This Saturday, Hartford State hosts RPI in Hartford, while Amherst hosts Bridgewater State in Amherst. Both games kick off at noon.

We went 4-1 picking winners last week and finished the regular season at 38-7 (.844). That ties our all-time high water mark for wins in a season. Our only miss last week was picking Williams to upset Amherst. The Lord Mammoths took care of business in Williamstown, while we correctly picked Wesleyan over Hartford State in the Turducken Bowl! We predicted a 24-23 Wesleyan victory. The Cardinals won 27-20. Now the question is whether we can keep our winning percentage above .800 against opponents from outside the friendly confines of the NESCAC.

NESCAC Headlines Heading into Week #10:

•   THREE NESCAC TEAMS MAKE THE NCAA PLAYOFFS! Who would have believed that the conference's first year of postseason eligibility would result in three teams receiving invitations? Congratulations to Hartford State, Amherst, and Wesleyan. All three have earned the opportunity to represent the NESCAC on the national stage.
•   Hartford State wins the lottery! After losing to Wesleyan 27-20 in the regular-season finale, the Bantams needed some help to secure the conference's automatic bid. They got it through a random draw. Three teams finish 8-1, and the NCAA automatic bid is determined by chance. You simply cannot make this stuff up!
•   Wesleyan gets a BYE! The Cardinals defeated Hartford State, shared the NESCAC Championship, earned an at-large invitation, and received a first-round bye. Wesleyan will travel to Springfield (9-1) on November 28. The Cardinals are ranked #24 nationally in the NCAA's National Power Index, making them the highest-rated NESCAC team. Not a bad way to begin the conference's NCAA playoff era.
•   Amherst gets a home game. The Lord Mammoths finished 8-1, with their only loss coming against Hartford State by three points. They host Bridgewater State, the 8-1 MASCAC champion. Amherst has an excellent opportunity to make history.
•   Hartford State draws a dangerous opponent. RPI comes to Hartford with an 8-2 record, having won seven consecutive games and captured the Liberty League Championship. The Engineers are averaging 36.5 points per game and allowing just 12.9. This is NOT going to be easy for the Bantams.
•   The NESCAC's reputation is on the line. We've spent decades arguing about how good the best NESCAC football teams really are. Some believe the conference is among the strongest in Division III. Others believe the NESCAC's lack of nonconference competition has inflated its reputation. Well, we're about to find out.
•   The NCAA bracket presents some fascinating possibilities. Hartford State would travel to undefeated Endicott with a victory over RPI. Amherst would travel to unbeaten Cortland with a win over Bridgewater State. And Wesleyan awaits Springfield in the second round. All three NESCAC teams are in the same quarter of the NCAA bracket. We could even see Wesleyan and Hartford State play AGAIN in the third round!
•   Wesleyan is the first NESCAC team to ever qualify for the 2nd round of the NCAA Division III playoffs.
•   The State of Maine is watching from home. Colby finished 2-7, UBates 1-8, and Bowdoin 0-9. A combined 3-24. While three NESCAC teams are preparing for the NCAA playoffs, the Maine schools are preparing for a very long offseason. Fortunately, there's always ice hockey.

Our upset special this week: Neither game! We're picking BOTH NESCAC teams to win their first-round NCAA matchups. Some might say we're being conference homers. We prefer to think we're finally getting an opportunity to prove what we've been saying for years.

Let's get to this week's games...
 
Bridgewater State University (8-1) at Amherst College (8-1): The Lord Mammoths Enter the Big Dance! For the first time in the long and distinguished history of Amherst College football, the Lord Mammoths will compete in the NCAA Division III Football Championship Tournament. And they'll do it at home! Amherst enters Saturday's game with an 8-1 record, a share of the NESCAC Championship, and an outstanding defense that has carried the team throughout the season. The Lord Mammoths finished their regular season with a 16-7 victory over Williams in Williamstown, securing their eighth victory, winning the Little 3 title, and keeping alive their hopes of receiving an NCAA at-large invitation. Those hopes became reality Sunday evening. Now Amherst gets an opportunity to demonstrate that NESCAC football can compete nationally. But don't expect Bridgewater State to roll over. The Bears enter the tournament 8-1, having captured the MASCAC Championship. They have one of the most productive offenses in New England Division III football, scoring 354 points in nine games, an average of 39.3 per contest. That's almost twice Amherst's scoring average. Bridgewater State has scored at least 34 points in seven games this season, including 63 against Curry, 55 against Dean, and 45 against Fitchburg State. The Bears can move the football. But the question is how they'll perform against a NESCAC defense like Amherst's. The Lord Mammoths are allowing just 15.3 points and approximately 256 total yards per game. Opponents are averaging fewer than 68 rushing yards per contest. That's outstanding defense. Amherst DL Jackson Duncan has been particularly effective, while Ty Kazanowsky, Noah Onkst, and Carson Skotak have helped anchor one of the NESCAC's most consistent defensive units. And let's not forget the Mammoths held Wesleyan to nine points earlier this season. The Cardinals averaged nearly 29 points per game and were arguably the NESCAC's most explosive offensive team. If Amherst can hold Wesleyan to nine points, we believe it can contain Bridgewater State. The bigger concern is the Amherst offense. The Lord Mammoths are averaging just 21.8 points per game and have struggled to finish drives throughout the season. Remember their 16-13 loss to Hartford State? Amherst generated 416 yards, made SIX trips into the red zone, and scored just 13 points. That's not going to win many NCAA playoff games. QB Marek Hill has been productive, throwing for more than 1,900 yards with 14 touchdowns. WRs Max Alexander, Jadon Davis, and Christian Moore provide legitimate receiving threats. But Amherst needs to generate greater offensive consistency, particularly in the running game. The Mammoths have averaged approximately 100 rushing yards per game, which places considerable pressure on Hill to make plays through the air. Bridgewater State's defense has also been vulnerable, allowing 192 points, or 21.3 per game. That's six more points per game than Amherst has surrendered. The Bears' only regular-season loss came against Worcester State, 35-34, a game that demonstrated both their offensive firepower and defensive vulnerability. Bridgewater State also needed a late comeback to defeat UMass Dartmouth 29-26. There will be opportunities for Amherst to score. The question is whether the Lord Mammoths can capitalize. Amherst wins if: The Mammoths' defense controls Bridgewater State's running game and forces the Bears into obvious passing situations. Amherst must make Bridgewater State earn its points through sustained drives rather than explosive plays. Hill protects the football and takes advantage of favorable passing matchups. Amherst cannot afford turnovers that give the Bears short fields. The Lord Mammoths improve their red-zone efficiency. Field goals aren't going to be enough against a team averaging nearly 40 points per game. Amherst controls time of possession and keeps the Bridgewater State offense on the sidelines. The Mammoths want a physical, relatively low-scoring contest. Bridgewater State wins if: The Bears establish their high-scoring offense early and force Amherst to play from behind. They generate explosive plays against the Amherst secondary and prevent the Mammoths from controlling the tempo. They take advantage of Amherst's offensive inconsistency and force Hill into passing situations where turnovers become more likely. They make Amherst win a shootout. The Bears would much rather play a game in the 30s than a defensive battle in the teens.

Our assessment (Factor/Advantage):
Offense: Bridgewater State
Defense: Amherst
Quarterback play: Amherst
Running game: Bridgewater State
Passing game: Bridgewater State
Special teams: Even
Home-field advantage: Amherst
Recent momentum: Even
Championship experience: Even
Coaching: Amherst

Our prediction: This is a fascinating matchup between two very different football teams. Bridgewater State wants to score points. Lots of them. Amherst wants to play defense, control the football, and win a physical contest. We believe the quality of the Amherst defense will be the difference. The Lord Mammoths have faced some very good offensive teams this season, including Wesleyan, Hartford State, and Hamilton. They have demonstrated the ability to limit explosive plays and keep games close. Bridgewater State has not faced a defense quite like Amherst's on a regular basis. We also believe the Lord Mammoths will find opportunities to move the football against a Bears defense that has allowed more than 21 points per game. The key will be converting those opportunities into touchdowns. We expect Bridgewater State to score early, forcing Amherst to play from behind. But we believe the Lord Mammoths will adjust defensively, control the second half, and get a late touchdown from Hill to take the lead. The Bears will have one final opportunity, but the Amherst defense will come up with a critical stop. And the Lord Mammoths will make history.

@Amherst 24 Bridgewater State 21
Point Spread: Amherst -4
Weather (courtesy of the Weather Channel): Except for a few afternoon clouds, mainly sunny. High 64F. Winds light and variable.


Nescacman

2026 Week 10 NESCACMAN Picks: NCAA Playoff Edition (page 2 of 2)

Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute (8-2) at Hartford State College (8-1): The Bantams' NCAA Playoff Debut. This is it. After more than 50 years of NESCAC football operating outside the NCAA playoff structure, Hartford State could become the first conference football program to win an NCAA Division III tournament game. What an extraordinary moment for the Hartford State football program. The Bantams enter the NCAA tournament at 8-1, having captured a share of the NESCAC Championship for the 13th time. Of course, their path to the tournament wasn't exactly conventional. Hartford State entered the final week undefeated and needing one more victory to win the conference championship outright. Instead, Wesleyan came to Hartford and knocked off the Bants 27-20, creating a three-way tie with Amherst. Then came the random draw. And somehow, Hartford State ended up with the automatic NCAA bid. Sometimes it's better to be lucky than good. Of course, the Bantams have been plenty good this season. Hartford State finished the regular season averaging 28.8 points per game while allowing just 10.6. The Bants have one of the best defenses in New England Division III football. But Saturday's opponent presents a serious challenge. RPI enters the tournament 8-2, having won seven consecutive games and captured the Liberty League Championship. The Engineers are averaging 36.5 points and 368.8 total yards per game. They also have an excellent defense, allowing just 12.9 points and 252.1 yards per game. Those are impressive numbers. RPI has allowed opponents to convert fewer than 30% of their third-down opportunities and has intercepted 18 passes this season. The Engineers also have an effective rushing attack, averaging 176.5 yards per game, led by RB Kayden White, who has rushed for 978 yards and 12 touchdowns. QB Micah Balzarini provides balance through the air, having thrown for 1,240 yards and 11 touchdowns. This isn't a one-dimensional offense. But RPI's season has not been without its challenges. The Engineers lost to Utica 38-14 and Brockport 45-10 in September before turning things around. Their seven-game winning streak includes impressive victories over Hobart, Ithaca, and Union. The victory at Ithaca was particularly impressive. RPI defeated the Bombers 14-10 in a defensive struggle, demonstrating that the Engineers can win low-scoring games against quality opponents. That should get Hartford State's attention. The Bantams' defense has been outstanding all season, but the offense has become increasingly inconsistent. Consider Hartford State's final four regular-season games: Bowdoin: Win 10-3; Middlebury: Win 26-23; Amherst: Win 16-13; Wesleyan: Loss 20-27. That's just 72 points in four games, an average of 18 per contest. Compare that with the Bantams' first four games, when they were scoring nearly 40 points per contest. Something has changed. Against Amherst, the Bantams generated only 219 yards of offense and failed to score an offensive touchdown. Against Wesleyan, QB Jaxon Carroll threw three interceptions, and the Bantams couldn't overcome the mistakes. The good news? Hartford State's defense has continued to play at an extremely high level. LB Lincoln Moore has been one of the best defensive players in the NESCAC, recording 90 tackles. Ethan Krauss and Shane Mosia have also been outstanding. The Bants allow just 69 rushing yards per game and have repeatedly demonstrated the ability to shut down opposing running attacks. That's going to be critical against RPI. Offensively, Carroll has thrown for more than 2,000 yards and 14 touchdowns, while WR Darison Hooper has been the team's most productive receiver, with 646 yards and seven touchdowns. RB Josh Woodford provides a solid rushing option, but the Bantams need more consistency up front. And perhaps most important, they need to protect the football. Against a defense that has recorded 18 interceptions, the Bants cannot afford another three-interception performance.

Why we're picking Hartford State:
1. The Bantams' defense is the real deal. Hartford State allows just 10.6 points per game, slightly better than RPI's 12.9. The Bants have an outstanding defensive front, talented linebackers, and an opportunistic secondary. They've also faced some very good offensive teams in Wesleyan, Amherst, and Hamilton. We believe Trinity's defense will be the best unit RPI has faced this season.
2. Home-field advantage matters. Playing in The Coop with the opportunity to win the NESCAC's first NCAA playoff game should provide an enormous emotional lift. The Bantams have been extremely difficult to beat at home over the years, and we expect a tremendous atmosphere in Hartford.
3. The Bantams have championship experience. HCOF Jeff Devanney has built one of the most consistently successful football programs in the NESCAC. While this is Trinity's first NCAA playoff appearance, the Bantams have participated in numerous championship-deciding games over the past two decades. They understand what it takes to win under pressure.
4. Hartford State should be able to challenge RPI's offensive line. The Engineers have been productive running the football, but the Bants allow only 69 rushing yards per game. If Hartford State can contain Kayden White and force RPI into third-and-long situations, the Bantams' defense will have opportunities to create turnovers and get off the field.

Why RPI could win:
1. The Engineers have a more productive offense. RPI is averaging 36.5 points per game compared with Hartford State's 28.8. And the disparity is even greater when looking at the Bantams' recent offensive production. RPI has scored 25 or more points in six of its last seven games.
2. RPI knows how to force turnovers. Eighteen interceptions in 10 games is an extraordinary number. Hartford State QB Jaxon Carroll struggled with turnovers against Wesleyan, and RPI will undoubtedly look to pressure him and create similar mistakes.
3. The Engineers are playing their best football of the season. Seven consecutive victories. That's impressive momentum. RPI has demonstrated considerable improvement since its two early-season losses. Meanwhile, the Bantams are coming off their first defeat of the season. Momentum favors the Engineers.
4. RPI has NCAA playoff experience. Unlike Hartford State, the Engineers have previously participated in the NCAA Division III Football Championship. RPI reached the national quarterfinals in 2021, and the program understands the preparation and intensity required for postseason football. That experience could be particularly valuable in a close game.

Our assessment (Factor/Advantage):
Offense: RPI
Defense: Hartford State
Quarterback play: Even
Running game: RPI
Passing game: Hartford State
Special teams: Even
Home-field advantage: Hartford State
Recent momentum: RPI
Championship experience: Hartford State
NCAA playoff experience: RPI
Coaching: Even

Our prediction: This is going to be a terrific football game. RPI comes to Hartford with one of the more productive offenses in "New Englandish" Division III football, an excellent defense, and considerable momentum. Hartford State has one of the nation's better defensive units and the advantage of playing at home. We believe the game will be decided by three things. First, can Hartford State stop RPI's running game? If the Bantams hold Kayden White in check and force the Engineers into obvious passing situations, Trinity's defense should be able to create opportunities. Second, can Jaxon Carroll protect the football? The Bantams cannot afford the turnovers that plagued them against Wesleyan. And third, can Trinity rediscover some of the offensive explosiveness it demonstrated earlier in the season? We think the answer is yes. We expect a physical, relatively low-scoring contest in the first half, with both defenses controlling the line of scrimmage. RPI will move the football, but we believe the Bantams' defense will tighten up in the red zone. Hartford State will generate a couple of explosive plays through the air, with Carroll connecting with Hooper for a critical touchdown. The Engineers will make things interesting late, but Trinity's defense will come up with one final stop to preserve the victory. And just like that, the NESCAC will have its first NCAA football playoff win!

@Hartford State 23 RPI 20
Point Spread: Hartford State -2.5
Weather: Sunny along with a few clouds. High near 65F. Winds light and variable.
 
NESCACMAN's Week 10 Picks at a Glance
Game/Predicted Winner/Score/Point Spread
Bridgewater State at Amherst/Amherst 24-21/Amherst -4
RPI at Hartford State/Hartford State 23-20/Hartford State -2.5
All point spreads are NESCACMAN's projected lines, not sportsbook odds.

What About Wesleyan?
The Cardinals have the week off after earning a first-round bye in the NCAA tournament. Wesleyan will travel to Springfield College on Saturday, November 28, for its first NCAA playoff game. Springfield enters the tournament 9-1, having won the NEWMAC Championship for the sixth consecutive season. The Pride are ranked #12 nationally in the NCAA's National Power Index and #24 in the D3football.com poll. Wesleyan is ranked #24 in the NPI. The Cardinals will face an extraordinarily disciplined Springfield triple option rushing attack, which presents a very different challenge from most of the offenses they've faced in the NESCAC. But Wesleyan also brings one of the conference's most explosive passing offenses and an outstanding defense that has recorded 17 interceptions this season. We believe this could be one of the most entertaining games of the second round. And wouldn't it be something if Wesleyan and Hartford State both advanced far enough to meet again in the NCAA tournament? The Turducken Bowl, Part II! We'll have much more on Wesleyan and Springfield in next week's picks.
 
Final Thoughts:
For more than 50 years, the NESCAC has been one of the few NCAA Division III football conferences that did not participate in the national championship tournament. That's over. Now three NESCAC teams are in the field, two are hosting first-round games, and one has already received a bye to the second round. Pretty impressive! But getting invited is one thing. Winning is another. We're about to find out whether the NESCAC's best football programs can compete with the rest of Division III. We've been arguing for years that they can. This Saturday, Hartford State and Amherst have the opportunity to prove it. We're picking both to win!

Good luck to all the student-athletes and coaches representing the NESCAC this Saturday.

Let's go NESCAC!

NESCACMAN's Track Record:
2026 Season: 38-7 (.844 winning percentage, through 9 weeks, 4-1 last week)
2025 Season: 32-13
2024 Season: 38-7
2023 Season: 31-14
2022 Season: 31-14
2021 Season: 33-12
2020 Season: 0-0 (COVID)
2019 Season: 33-12
2018 Season: 36-9
2017 Season: 35-10
2016 Season: 32-8
2015 Season: 30-10
2014 Season: 30-10
2013 Season: 32-8
Career: 431-134 (.763 winning percentage, 13 seasons)

**********

Follow NESCACMAN on X: @realnescacman

**********
Nine Weeks: A NESCAC Football Podcast

Available Soon! Available wherever you get your podcasts!

9 Weeks: A NESCAC Football Podcast S.3 Ep.10 (Special Guests: Wesleyan University LB Austin Baker, Wesleyan University QB Matt Fitzsimons, Amherst College Head Coach EJ Mills, and D3football.com's Patrick Coleman).

Nine Weeks: A NESCAC Football Podcast is the first podcast of its kind in NESCAC history. Hosted by Chris Grace (play-by-play announcer for Wesleyan) and Dave Bagatelle (Wesleyan Alum, former player, and NESCAC expert), our weekly show features coach and player interviews, game analysis, rankings, previews, and predictions. And now, for the first time, we've got NCAA playoff football to talk about! We'll review the historic three-way tie for the NESCAC Championship, Hartford State's automatic qualification, the at-large selections of Amherst and Wesleyan, and the first-round matchups. We'll also preview Wesleyan's upcoming second-round game at Springfield and discuss what the NESCAC needs to do to establish itself as a national football power.

The podcast is available wherever you get your podcasts including YouTube, Facebook, Apple and Spotify. Search for "9 Weeks NESCAC"...the first and only podcast of its kind.
 
Thank you to our sponsors Sloane and Walsh, LLP, Gameday Sports, and Noank Village Boatyard.
 
If you have questions, feedback, ideas or are a player or a coach and would like to appear on our show, please email us at: 9weeksnescac@gmail.com

Follow us on X (aka Twitter): @nineweeksnescac
Follow us on Instagram: @nineweeksnescac
Facebook: Nine Weeks: A NESCAC Football Podcast (https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1EbgGxDZRd/)
YouTube: 9 Weeks Nescac (https://www.youtube.com/@nineweeksnescac)
Spotify Podcasts: 9 Weeks Nescac
Apple Podcasts: 9 Weeks Nescac

Look for NESCACMAN's weekly predictions and point spreads at nescacfootballreport.com. The NESCAC Football report is a website dedicated to all things NESCAC football, including team previews, weekly game previews and power rankings, game recaps. and now NCAA playoff coverage. The site now provides its followers with NESCACMAN's weekly game lines and predicted scores.

The NESCAC is finally going dancing. Let the games begin!

Nescacman

2026 NESCACMAN Football Regular Season Awards Predictions

The coaches meet tomorrow to vote on the 2026 NESCAC Football Season Awards and make their All-NESCAC selections. We expect them to announce their selections next week before Thanksgiving.

Following one of the most competitive NESCAC seasons in recent memory, Amherst, Trinity and Wesleyan finished as tri-champions with identical 8-1 records. With the regular season complete, here are NESCACMAN's 2026 award predictions, based on individual performance, team success and how I expect the conference coaches to vote.

Award/ Should Win/ Will Win:
Offensive Player of the Year/QB Matt Fitzsimons, Wesleyan/QB Matt Fitzsimons, Wesleyan
Defensive Player of the Year/ DB Tommy Kilroy, Wesleyan/ LB Lincoln Moore, Hartford State
Rookie of the Year/ RB Jack Fabiano, Williams/ RB Jack Fabiano, Williams
Coaching Staff of the Year/ Wesleyan (Dan DiCenzo)/ Amherst (E.J. Mills)


NESCACMAN Analysis:

Offensive Player of the Year: Fitzsimons deserves to repeat after leading Wesleyan to its third consecutive NESCAC championship. He completed 69.7% of his passes for 2,236 yards and 13 touchdowns and led the conference in passing efficiency (165.7). Hamilton quarterback Luke Kurzum (2,410 passing yards) and receiver Matthew Kearns (74 receptions, 1,003 yards, 10 TDs) deserve consideration, but Fitzsimons gets our vote.

Defensive Player of the Year: Wesleyan sophomore Tommy Kilroy led the NESCAC with five interceptions, including a pick-six, and made game-changing plays throughout the season. Hartford State linebacker Lincoln Moore recorded 90 tackles and four sacks, making him a formidable candidate. My prediction is that the coaches favor Moore's consistency and Hartford State's defensive success.

Rookie of the Year: Williams running back Jack Fabiano was sensational, rushing for 721 yards and eight touchdowns in just six games, averaging 120.2 yards per contest. Despite missing three games, his production makes him our clear favorite.

Coaching Staff of the Year: Dan DiCenzo and Wesleyan deserve recognition for winning a third consecutive NESCAC championship, capped by a 27-20 victory at Trinity. However, E.J. Mills and Amherst went from 5-4 in 2025 to 8-1 in 2026, claiming their first share of a NESCAC title since 2015. That remarkable turnaround may sway the coaches toward Amherst.

These are NESCACMAN predictions, not officially announced 2026 conference awards.

blue_jays

Quote from: Nescacman on Yesterday at 04:54:59 PM
Quote from: Trin9-0 on Yesterday at 04:11:25 PM
Quote from: blue_jays on Yesterday at 04:00:13 PMJust wait till the Cortland game in Round 2...

To be clear, this was more a joke about the academic discrepancy between the two schools than my assumed outcome on the field this Saturday. Bridgewater State has an acceptance rate of about 88% while Amherst is closer to 8%.

I do think the Mammoths will prevail this weekend but have no illusions that if they do they would win at Cortland.

You have to remember that when you get beyond the NESCAC Board, nuance and humor gets somewhat lost. The whole "NESCAC in the play-offs" thing and "NESCAC got 3 spots" thing seems to have really struck a chord amongst the D3 masses (to say the least). Type "NESCAC" and "D3football" into Twitter search and be prepared to duck!

Our Round 1 picks will be posted either tonight or tomorrow but, shocker of all shockers, we would not be in the least bit surprised to see both Amherst and Hartford State come way with Round 1 wins. In fact, they probably both deserve to be favored (they did get home games after all).

NM

Having a closed loop of only conference games is the issue people have, and it screws up the NPI as a result. No way to know how good the teams are or not compared to the rest of the region or nation. 1 non-con game would be a step in the right direction, but sounds like the NESCAC Presidents aren't interested in that. When you're the only conference getting 3 teams in, people aren't going to like it and rightfully so. Not even the WIAC should have gotten 3 in this year and they are most deserving of such year in and year out.
The East coast/region hasn't been strong in postseason play relative to this era of dominance by the WIAC, Mount Unions and North Centrals of the world. First example that came to mind was 2024 North Central winning their NCAA quarterfinal and semifinal over Springfield and Susquehanna by a combined score of 93-3. Hence why everyone is dubious of NESCAC teams, regardless if they beat their regional neighbors in the first round or not.

Trin9-0

One unexpected benefit of the NESCAC finally allowing postseason play in football and subsequently getting three postseason bids is that the league's decades-long practice of intentionally insular scheduling is now part of a national discourse on equity in college sports.

Basically the lesson is... don't f**k with Midwesterners and Texans when it comes to their football.

On Twitter, d3cutline has done some excellent work already to examine how the NESCAC's incestuous schedule impacts (or more accurately, doesn't impact) NPI scores. I recommend checking it out. My favorite is their debunking of the argument that a 10-game NESCAC football season would increase travel and thus hurt academics. They compare the travel schedules of a "typical NESCAC schedule" for men's basketball, baseball, and men's lacrosse. The findings:   
           
Total Miles    Weekday Miles
Baseball
3,960
3,500
Lacrosse
2,300
420
Basketball
2,285
1,105
Football
1,610
0

Finally, for those making their way to the NESCAC board to whine about the injustice of three teams making the field because we don't play out of conference games. You're preaching to the choir. We want an out of conference game as well. And a bye week while we're at it. Unfortunately, we don't have a say. It took us decades to get to this point and the Presidents have essentially told football to back off on asking for anything more.

The good news is that having three 1 loss teams in the NESCAC is exceedingly rare. Prior to this season it has happened only three times since the conference was formed in 1971 and in only one of those instances did it occur when all three one-loss teams each played one another. Now, having two teams with one or fewer losses is much more common. Since the league went to a conference only schedule in 1992 it has happened 18 times.

2023 - Trinity 8-1, Middlebury 8-1
2021 - Williams 9-0, Trinity 8-1
2019 - Middlebury 9-0, Wesleyan 8-1
2018 - Trinity 8-1, Amherst 8-1
2016 - Trinity 8-0, Tufts 7-1
2015 - Amherst 8-0, Trinity 7-1
2014 - Amherst 8-0, Wesleyan 7-1
2013 - Amherst 7-1, Middlebury 7-1, Wesleyan 7-1
2012 - Trinity 8-0, Middlebury 7-1
2011 - Amherst 8-0, Trinity 7-1
2010 - Williams 8-0, Trinity 7-1
2006 - Williams 8-0, Trinity 7-1
2005 - Trinity 8-0, Colby 7-1
2002 - Trinity 7-1, Williams 7-1
2001 - Williams 8-0, Amherst 7-1
2000 - Amherst 7-1, Colby 7-1, Middlebury 7-1
1998 - Williams 8-0, Tufts 7-1
1997 - Amherst 7-1, Wesleyan 7-1, Williams 7-1
1996 - Amherst 7-1, Trinity 7-1
1994 - Williams 8-0, Colby 7-1
1993 - Trinity 8-0, Williams 7-1
 
All this is to say that if nothing changes with the league schedules or NPI dials, we should get used to seeing two NESCAC teams getting bids roughly every other year and three teams getting bids about once every 10 years.
NESCAC CHAMPS: 1978, 1980, 1983, 1987, 1991, 1993, 1996, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2008, 2012, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2022, 2023, 2025, 2026
UNDEFEATED SEASONS: 1911, 1915, 1934, 1949, 1954, 1955, 1993, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2008, 2012, 2016, 2022

CarollFan

I'm not sure an additional non conference game is going to appease those complaining. Then the discussion will be who they are scheduling for non-conference.

At the end of the day with the current NPI formula 22 out of 23, 1 loss teams made the playoffs. So let's say they scheduled a sub .500 non conference game, won and still got in.

I could make the case WIAC schools have an advantage with 3 non-conference games because if they win those 3 they only have to use 2 from conference, not having to grab wins from the lower half of the conference.

ccd494

I got onto this board as a fan of Husson football.  Given the amount of whining about the ECFC getting an auto-bid, no one will ever be happy.

Also, those baseball numbers are likely skewed by spring break trips to Florida.

Nescacman

We think a lot of this (not all, mind you) will be settled on the field over the next two Saturday's. Let's see how this all pans out.

As someone said, you can't make everyone happy.

NM

Trin9-0

With just 3 days until we get to see how the NESCAC fares vs. the rest of the D3 football world I thought it would be interesting to share how Logan Hansen (of Hansen Ratings) used some very creative thinking to account for how he rates NESCAC schools along with the rest of D3 without any data points vs. out of conference opponents. You can view the full rationale at his twitter account.

Hansen measured Director's Cup points, endowment size, Pell Grant rates, male student enrollments, median standardized test scores, local high school football participation rates, in-state undergraduate enrollments, roster size, heights and weights of players on rosters, % of roster who are seniors, roster retention rate, admission yield, % of roster from in-state, and median distance from hometowns to campus, and more.

After all of this data collection and analysis here's his list of the top 10 most similar schools:
  • Washington & Lee
  • Rochester
  • Pomona-Pitzer
  • Carleton
  • Denison
  • RPI
  • Claremont-Mudd-Scripps
  • Carnegie Mellon
  • Case Wester Reserve
  • MIT

I think that list passes the smell test. Hansen's conclusion is that the NESCAC's biggest hurdle to overcome is their roster sizes, but acknowledges that for the playoff caliber teams it's artificially constrained and different from schools who simply can't recruit larger rosters. He believes the biggest structural benefit is the league's broad based athletic success and the size of NESCAC athletes. Based on his data, only the WIAC has larger athletes.

A fascinating conversation and really excited to see what the top teams in the NESCAC look like against out of conference competition. If anything, this reinforces my assumption that Amherst will roll Bridgewater State while Trinity and RPI will be extremely close.
NESCAC CHAMPS: 1978, 1980, 1983, 1987, 1991, 1993, 1996, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2008, 2012, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2022, 2023, 2025, 2026
UNDEFEATED SEASONS: 1911, 1915, 1934, 1949, 1954, 1955, 1993, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2008, 2012, 2016, 2022

CarollFan

Logan has Amherst as a 3 TD favorite to win and Trinity as a slight underdog by 4.2 points.

https://hansenratings.com/projections/2026/round-1/