FB: Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference

Started by admin, August 16, 2005, 05:19:08 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

faunch, OzJohnnie and 60 Guests are viewing this topic.

hazzben

Don't disagree, we knew what NPI was and wasn't. However ...
- Pat made the point about the SCAC, that 1 bid was literally all Bethel needed to make the field.
- No one fully grasped the way the NESCAC bubble would produce 3 bids, nor can you expect the Bethel AD predict that.
- Easy to say NPI disincentives scheduling blue blood programs. Sure, maybe we don't schedule NCC again, but Bethel has the same problem as SJU, Wartburg, NCC, UWW/UWL/UWP/UWRF have, there are also a ton of teams that have zero desire to schedule us.

To me the latter point is the major problem. If programs ranked 15-100 were willing to schedule Top 15 teams, this wouldn't be the issue that it is. NPI punishes you for losing to a top 15 program, meanwhile a huge swath of D3 teams won't schedule a Top 15 program in Non-con.

Scheduling NCC, and even losing, made Bethel a better team and more prepared for playoff competition. Another game against UNWSP would have made neither team any better, but it would have gotten Bethel into the playoffs. That's an asinine tradeoff to make teams pick between. Not to mention, SJU didn't get any NPI favors in seeding/quad placement from being aggressive. NPI doesn't even fully reward you if you win, because it's a terrible metric and actually ranking the quality of a team.

NCC2010

Quote from: GoldandBlueBU on Today at 03:19:45 PM
Quote from: DuffMan on Today at 03:06:46 PMThe NPI formula for '26 didn't change from '25. I applaud Bethel for scheduling NCC, but they knew the potential repurcussions of it.

To be clear, I'm not saying that I am in favor of the current formula (or "dials"), but at least it is transparent.

Yeah - that is where I am it...they knew the risks, and I'm still glad they elected to push the program / team.  I do wish that the system encouraged scheduling this sort of game, rather than incentivized picking up a blowout.

Tough way to end their career for the seniors.

Go get 'em SJU!  :-\

I'm not positive but I think if NCC goes 10-0 instead of 9-1 Bethel gets in. 

hazzben

Per usual, Logan has the data to backup what we are trying to say.

In the current NPI dial settings, according to LH - if the goal is maximizing playoff odds, playing a Top 10 team is the worst value proposition for improving your playoff resume.

CarollFan

I think you're both right but NCC ends up 9-1 and Bethel doesn't get in.

I don't know if you guys saw how Heidelberg got in.
They had 2 games help them yesterday. Maryville (Tenn) and Marietta.
Heidelberg had beaten Maryville in a non-conference game.

Maryville scores the winning TD with 15 seconds left on 4rth down.
Marietta scores 28 in the 4rth Q, winning TD with 14 seconds left to win by 1.

Mister36

Quote from: CarollFan on Today at 04:38:55 PMI think you're both right but NCC ends up 9-1 and Bethel doesn't get in.

I don't know if you guys saw how Heidelberg got in.
They had 2 games help them yesterday. Maryville (Tenn) and Marietta.
Heidelberg had beaten Maryville in a non-conference game.

Maryville scores the winning TD with 15 seconds left on 4rth down.
Marietta scores 28 in the 4rth Q, winning TD with 14 seconds left to win by 1.

Consider me 200% mad

USee

And last year, with the extra bid, Bethel gets in. Wheaton two years ago lost @UWO and v NCC and was the first team out like Bethel this year. They responded by dropping the mid WIAC team and scheduling Mt Union. Last year they lost @Mt Union and @NCC and got in and made a run to the quarterfinals. So a year ago I was saying, "Scheduling up helped us" because the NPI of Mt Union a year ago was much better than the NPI of UWO two years ago (NCC being similar).  Then the NCAA granted more access and less at large bids and the incentive to schedule up is gone.

None of that was/is foreseeable by an AD, who typically schedules games 1-3 years in advance.

AO

Quote from: art76 on Today at 11:16:51 AM
Quote from: DuffMan on Today at 10:54:36 AMGreg made the point on today's podcast that even with the previous system, Bethel would have very much been a bubble team at 8-2. 0-2 vs. regionally ranked teams. It's definitely an imperfect system, but it is what we've got.
Something else to entertain is to limit the number of AQs, by making the minimum number of teams in a conference go up to 7 or 8, or making a minimum loss cut-off line of 3 losses a year for any conference champion. This year a rule of that nature would automatically eliminate the UMAC from this year's playoffs. They can still have their conference champions, but then to award them a playoff spot where they stand almost no chance to win a game against anyone else in the tournament is just cruel and humiliating, both for them, and the potential teams that stand better chances of winning games in the tourney.
I assure you that we do not consider this playoff game to be cruel or humiliating. 

That said, I certainly share the frustration with NPI that everyone has. The messaging remains that if your metric does not consider margin of victory it's almost meaningless.