FB: Liberty League

Started by admin, August 16, 2005, 04:58:34 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 34 Guests are viewing this topic.

Ice Bear

Congrats to RPI on winning the Shoes. RPI is the better team and I am 100% rooting for them next week.

Also, a great effort by Ithaca today. They left it all on the field and represented the LL well.
A long time fan of DIII Football!

Bartman

RPI is flying high right now. Congrats on beating a very good Union squad. Hoping you get a fair matchup in the NCAAs
The Bombers played very  well today. Will Ithaca consider participating in an ECAC bowl this year?
Glad my Yellowjacket pick panned out.
Hobart is really peaking right now and the last few games got their bench some great minutes. Looking forward to a good ECAC matchup.
I think the top four LL teams are all very competitive D3 teams. We didn't have a good OOC result and the bottom 2 teams are not competitive at all.
I really hope RPi wins a couple of games and we end the season on a good note.
"I never graduated from Iowa, but I was only there for two terms - Truman's and Eisenhower's."
Alex Karras
"I have two weapons, my arms, my legs and my brain"
Michael Vick
"Nobody in football should be called a genius. A genius is a guy like Norman Einstein" Joe Theism

Unionpalooza

Welp, after a self-imposed two=month suspension for being too prone to be a dick on these boards, it seems safe to return.  I'll save my thoughts on the Union season for now so I don't immediately regress.

Kudos to Ithaca for a game effort in Cortaca - based on the head to heads with Union, I thought the Bombers would get crushed, but they were in it the whole way.  I feel like Ithaca sort of missed their window this year - this was as senior-laden a team as they'll have for a while.

I'm going to miss watching Kayden White run, though not against Union. With three NESCAC teams in the playoffs and seeded in a place where they ought to host the play-in round, RPI will almost certainly get one of them one the road - likely Trinity, maybe Wesleyan.  Fitch probably plays at Amherst, with the winner going to Endicott in round two.  Eastern will head to whichever of Trinity and Wesleyan RPI does not get.  For round two, Cortland, Utica, and Springfield will all be possible for RPI.  But there is basically one too many road teams in the East for the second round, and someone is going to get shipped further west to a Baldwin-Wallace or somesuch.

Hobart is my early league favorite for 2027.

Unionpalooza

Quote from: Unionpalooza on November 14, 2026, 07:28:38 PMWelp, after a self-imposed two=month suspension for being too prone to be a dick on these boards, it seems safe to return.  I'll save my thoughts on the Union season for now so I don't immediately regress.

Kudos to Ithaca for a game effort in Cortaca - based on the head to heads with Union, I thought the Bombers would get crushed, but they were in it the whole way.  I feel like Ithaca sort of missed their window this year - this was as senior-laden a team as they'll have for a while.

I'm going to miss watching Kayden White run, though not against Union. With three NESCAC teams in the playoffs and seeded in a place where they ought to host the play-in round, RPI will almost certainly get one of them one the road - likely Trinity, maybe Wesleyan.  Fitch probably plays at Amherst, with the winner going to Endicott in round two.  Eastern will head to whichever of Trinity and Wesleyan RPI does not get.  For round two, Cortland, Utica, and Springfield will all be possible for RPI.  But there is basically one too many road teams in the East for the second round, and someone is going to get shipped further west to a Baldwin-Wallace or somesuch.

Hobart is my early league favorite for 2027.

Meant Bridgewater State, not Fitchburg, likely to play Amherst.

Unionpalooza

Oh, and I can't help but point out that, of the top 4 teams in the D3F preseason poll this year, only one even made the playoffs.  Out of the top 10, only four. Absolutely wild.

Bartman

Quote from: Unionpalooza on November 14, 2026, 08:33:16 PMOh, and I can't help but point out that, of the top 4 teams in the D3F preseason poll this year, only one even made the playoffs.  Out of the top 10, only four. Absolutely wild.
Glad to see you back Palooza. Looking forward to your analysis of the Union season. Happy to see Hobart as your early 2027 favorite. I'm pretty optimistic about next season despite losing a few great Seniors.I think we will challenge RPI as the best Defense as our underclassmen were extremely productive and will be nasty veterans next year.
"I never graduated from Iowa, but I was only there for two terms - Truman's and Eisenhower's."
Alex Karras
"I have two weapons, my arms, my legs and my brain"
Michael Vick
"Nobody in football should be called a genius. A genius is a guy like Norman Einstein" Joe Theism

ICGrad

So I hate to say it, but after reading this article, I find myself agreeing with Mach:

https://d3football.com/notables/2026/11/week11-recap

So 3 NESCAC teams get in, and the article clearly states they get in purely based on record, as SoS doesn't really matter with the current NPI formula. As I said the other day, I largely don't have a problem with this, as teams that go 9-1 getting a bid isn't that troubling and I don't see this as being an every-year kind of thing. Whatever.

Then a little further down, the same article declares that 9-1 Lake Forest lost the AQ to Monmouth but won't be getting in because "Lake Forest's strength of schedule was not enough to get the team in the playoffs..."

Huh?!? What now?

How does Lake Forest have too low a SoS to get into the tourney? How is their SoS below the imaginary SoS assigned to the NESCAC?

Did the person writing that article even remember what they wrote two paragraphs before?

If I were a Lake Forest fan, I'd be pretty outraged right now.

ICGrad

Quote from: Unionpalooza on November 14, 2026, 08:33:16 PMOh, and I can't help but point out that, of the top 4 teams in the D3F preseason poll this year, only one even made the playoffs.  Out of the top 10, only four. Absolutely wild.

Equally interesting is how wide-open this year's tournament is going to be.

Most years there's a clear favorite going in; this year, any of the top 5 teams would be a good bet to win it. Cortland @ #9 can't be discounted. I'm sure there are others.

Unionpalooza

Quote from: ICGrad on November 15, 2026, 08:17:35 AMSo I hate to say it, but after reading this article, I find myself agreeing with Mach:

https://d3football.com/notables/2026/11/week11-recap

So 3 NESCAC teams get in, and the article clearly states they get in purely based on record, as SoS doesn't really matter with the current NPI formula. As I said the other day, I largely don't have a problem with this, as teams that go 9-1 getting a bid isn't that troubling and I don't see this as being an every-year kind of thing. Whatever.

Then a little further down, the same article declares that 9-1 Lake Forest lost the AQ to Monmouth but won't be getting in because "Lake Forest's strength of schedule was not enough to get the team in the playoffs..."

Huh?!? What now?

How does Lake Forest have too low a SoS to get into the tourney? How is their SoS below the imaginary SoS assigned to the NESCAC?

Did the person writing that article even remember what they wrote two paragraphs before?

If I were a Lake Forest fan, I'd be pretty outraged right now.

That article totally overstates the extent to which SOS is unimportant in the NPI; the formula certainly doesn't give SOS as much weight as many folks think it should, but it still matters.

Lake Forest is a perfect example. They're in an 11 team league, and they didn't play the best team in the league this year (Monmouth), and played one non-conf against 3-7 Greenville. That's enough of a ding to SOS that they finished behind six 2 or 3 loss teams in NPI, including Heidelberg (who got it) and Bethel (who didn't). 

The NESCACs got in because of their winning percentage and the fact that their SOS was perfectly average. But they will all be seeded behind sixteen other 1 loss teams, and reason is those other teams have above-average SOS.

But a lot of the NPI haters talk like just because SOS doesn't matter as much as they want, it doesn't matter at all.


ICGrad

#58029
Quote from: Unionpalooza on November 15, 2026, 09:33:28 AMThe NESCACs got in because of their winning percentage and the fact that their SOS was perfectly average. But they will all be seeded behind sixteen other 1 loss teams, and reason is those other teams have above-average SOS.

But a lot of the NPI haters talk like just because SOS doesn't matter as much as they want, it doesn't matter at all.

But the NESCAC's SoS wasn't perfectly average. Nobody knows what it is because no teams in the league played any outside games. For all we know, the NESCAC could be the worst league in the country; they don't even have wins against 3-7 non-NESCAC teams.

The NESCAC was assigned a pre-determined SoS as a league, and that was high enough for two of their 9-1 teams to get in the playoffs over a 9-1 team from another league. That's pretty indefensible if you ask me.

ETA: A 10-game season with few out-of-conference games provides far too small a sample size for the NPI to be meaningful/reliable. I'm not an NPI hater at all; seemed to work well for lacrosse, and it's a huge step up from RPI. But for football, we would be better served with a selection committee...which in effect is what we have here, as someone rigged the system to elevate (or assign) the NESCAC a SoS that their teams didn't earn.

Caz Bombers

Part of me wants to see the 3 NESCAC teams waltz through the bracket doing an Elle from Legally Blonde ("What? Like it's hard?")

The whining I'm seeing on social media and elsewhere in the D3 community is performative and unbecoming.

ICGrad

Quote from: Caz Bombers on November 15, 2026, 10:03:41 AMPart of me wants to see the 3 NESCAC teams waltz through the bracket doing an Elle from Legally Blonde ("What? Like it's hard?")

The whining I'm seeing on social media and elsewhere in the D3 community is performative and unbecoming.

No whining here. Just want reasonable criteria followed. Either SoS matters or it doesn't.

It's like the pretzel-twisting we're seeing to justify Alabama getting the #3 ranking in the CFP. Don't apply one set of criteria to certain teams, and another set to other teams. Be fair, transparent, and consistent.

Unionpalooza

Quote from: ICGrad on November 15, 2026, 10:01:50 AM
Quote from: Unionpalooza on November 15, 2026, 09:33:28 AMThe NESCACs got in because of their winning percentage and the fact that their SOS was perfectly average. But they will all be seeded behind sixteen other 1 loss teams, and reason is those other teams have above-average SOS.

But a lot of the NPI haters talk like just because SOS doesn't matter as much as they want, it doesn't matter at all.

But the NESCAC's SoS wasn't perfectly average. Nobody knows what it is because no teams in the league played any outside games. For all we know, the NESCAC could be the worst league in the country; they don't even have wins against 3-7 non-NESCAC teams.

The NESCAC was assigned a pre-determined SoS as a league, and that was high enough for two of their 9-1 teams to get in the playoffs over a 9-1 team from another league. That's pretty indefensible if you ask me.

ETA: A 10-game season with few out-of-conference games provides far too small a sample size for the NPI to be meaningful/reliable. I'm not an NPI hater at all; seemed to work well for lacrosse, and it's a huge step up from RPI. But for football, we would be better served with a selection committee...which in effect is what we have here, as someone rigged the system to elevate (or assign) the NESCAC a SoS that their teams didn't earn.

Totally fair, but the sample size a problem for everything. 10 games with a few OOC isn't enough data for a model to be meaningful, but it's also not enough data for a selections committee, either. There's just no reliable way to tell whether Benedictine or Montclair St. is the better team, whether by numbers or by human judgment; the whole thing's a fool's errand. If I have to choose between a flawed but objective and transparent way to do that and a flawed but subjective and opaque way to do that, I'm OK with the former.

FWIW, I've long advocated for going back to a regional bracket approach, with at-large bids based on in-region records. There, I think there's enough germane data to trust a selection committee with differentiating a smaller number of teams with more comparative data points. Per your comment, I'd also be fine with a rule that requires that you play OOC games (or even a minimum number of OOC games) to be eligible for an at-large.

Bartman

It will be interesting to see how the  NESCAC teams perform. RPI has a good chance of playing a NESCAC team in the first round.
"I never graduated from Iowa, but I was only there for two terms - Truman's and Eisenhower's."
Alex Karras
"I have two weapons, my arms, my legs and my brain"
Michael Vick
"Nobody in football should be called a genius. A genius is a guy like Norman Einstein" Joe Theism

ICGrad

Quote from: Unionpalooza on November 15, 2026, 10:31:32 AMFWIW, I've long advocated for going back to a regional bracket approach, with at-large bids based on in-region records. There, I think there's enough germane data to trust a selection committee with differentiating a smaller number of teams with more comparative data points. Per your comment, I'd also be fine with a rule that requires that you play OOC games (or even a minimum number of OOC games) to be eligible for an at-large.

Regional approach would be a huge improvement. I also have no issue with your second suggestion.