FB: Liberty League

Started by admin, August 16, 2005, 04:58:34 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 34 Guests are viewing this topic.

Caz Bombers

I would like to see the NPI abandoned solely in football due to as said above low sample size and replaced with Bill Connelly's SP+ advanced metrics that actually measure football performance on football fields in football games and not just Win or Lose.

Ice Bear

#58036
I'm looking forward to seeing the NESCAC teams in the playoffs, especially three of them. This will give us a VERY good idea about what we've all been wondering for so long, where does the NESCAC stack up in relation to rest of d3 (especially playoff d3 teams).
A long time fan of DIII Football!

Machiavelli

Let's get this show on the road already! LOL. Fun weekend in Troy. Solid game by the Engineers. Nothing too flashy.  Just business. Shoes are back where they belong. Aside from one Union parent losing her mind at the end of the game over a roast beef sandwich that her son might have dropped if it were tossed to him, it was mostly a respectful crowd as well. Now let's figure out next week. NESCAC is already the odds on favorite to take the title. Might not even want to show up.

Machiavelli

Trinity it is! On that note, I know it's some weird tiebreaker coin flip junk measuring thing for the AQ, but does anyone else find it completely ass backwards where 3 teams finished 8-1 with a mathematical tie in an incestual conference, but the AQ didn't get a bye while the other 2 did? Feels odd. Anyway, who gives a sh!t. Let's go!

Machiavelli

Sorry sorry, only one bye. Still interesting.

Patrick Coleman

Quote from: ICGrad on November 15, 2026, 08:17:35 AMHow does Lake Forest have too low a SoS to get into the tourney? How is their SoS below the imaginary SoS assigned to the NESCAC?

The NESCAC SOS is flat essentially .500, no non-conference games.

Lake Forest's was even lower than that. Hope this helps.

Quote from: ICGrad on November 15, 2026, 08:17:35 AMDid the person writing that article even remember what they wrote two paragraphs before?

Yes, I did not forget.
Publisher. Questions? Check our FAQ for D3f, D3h.
Quote from: old 40 on September 25, 2007, 08:23:57 PMLet's discuss (sports) in a positive way, sometimes kidding each other with no disrespect.

Patrick Coleman

Quote from: ICGrad on November 15, 2026, 10:01:50 AMBut the NESCAC's SoS wasn't perfectly average.

It was for purposes of the NPI.
Publisher. Questions? Check our FAQ for D3f, D3h.
Quote from: old 40 on September 25, 2007, 08:23:57 PMLet's discuss (sports) in a positive way, sometimes kidding each other with no disrespect.

Unionpalooza

Quote from: Machiavelli on November 15, 2026, 05:23:02 PMTrinity it is! On that note, I know it's some weird tiebreaker coin flip junk measuring thing for the AQ, but does anyone else find it completely ass backwards where 3 teams finished 8-1 with a mathematical tie in an incestual conference, but the AQ didn't get a bye while the other 2 did? Feels odd. Anyway, who gives a sh!t. Let's go!

Super fun matchup - those teams compete head to head for recruits all the time these days. It would be awesome to see Union line up against a NESCAC team again for the first time in 35 years, though with the current coaching staff, I'm not holding my breath.

ICGrad

Quote from: Patrick Coleman on November 15, 2026, 05:37:47 PM
Quote from: ICGrad on November 15, 2026, 08:17:35 AMHow does Lake Forest have too low a SoS to get into the tourney? How is their SoS below the imaginary SoS assigned to the NESCAC?

The NESCAC SOS is flat essentially .500, no non-conference games.

Lake Forest's was even lower than that. Hope this helps.


Doesn't help at all. Why was it flat? That seems entirely arbitrary and unfair to teams like Lake Forest. If anything, instead of rewarding teams who play in conferences that schedule no outside competition, the algorithm should punish them. Even moreso when those teams don't play the same 10 game schedule that most other teams do.

UfanBill

#58044
Quote from: Unionpalooza on November 15, 2026, 05:47:48 PM
Quote from: Machiavelli on November 15, 2026, 05:23:02 PMTrinity it is! On that note, I know it's some weird tiebreaker coin flip junk measuring thing for the AQ, but does anyone else find it completely ass backwards where 3 teams finished 8-1 with a mathematical tie in an incestual conference, but the AQ didn't get a bye while the other 2 did? Feels odd. Anyway, who gives a sh!t. Let's go!

Super fun matchup - those teams compete head to head for recruits all the time these days. It would be awesome to see Union line up against a NESCAC team again for the first time in 35 years, though with the current coaching staff, I'm not holding my breath.

When will Union next play a NESCAC school? Union football came into prominence in the early 1980's when they were still regularly scheduling NESCAC teams. During that decade they won their last 6 against Colby, won 6 of 7 from Hamilton, last 6 from Williams , last 4 from Middlebury and last 2 from Trinity. Their last game against a NESCAC foe was a 51-19 monkey-stomp over Hamilton on November 26, 1991 and yes, I was there. ;D I miss going to those beautiful campuses in the fall. 

Union's season while disappointing was pretty predictable. Coming into the season without an experienced Quarterback and no running game they had to rely on the defense. A defense that showed very well until they wore down late in games. A factor was their LL 1st team LB John Droggitis missed considerable time and actually was relegated to a backup role when healthy enough to play. QB Luke Sheehan had a good season but it was attributed mostly to the talent of his wide receivers as Sheehan's arm strength leaves a lot to be desired and he's certainly not the running threat Patch Flanagan was. Positives for next year Sheehan is back. The O-line has youth, size and now experience. Some excellent WR's are back and the defense will still be solid...All in all the Garnet won the games they should have won comfortably and lost to three tournament teams Cortland, Susquehanna and RPI plus Hobart and Ithaca. Very respectable.   

My thoughts on the NESCAC getting three teams in the tourney...I feel it was destined. Amherst will likely get by  Bridgewater St and then be humbled by Cortland.  Trinity will struggle with RPI's defense and end their season and Wesleyan has the best shot to advance by squeaking by Springfield but then run up against Endicott, the true Beast of New England.       
"You don't stop playing because you got old, you got old because you stopped playing" 🏈🏀⚾🎿⛳

IC798891

Endicott/Cortland is going to be a great QF matchup

stlawus

Really is convenient how much the NESCAC benefits from NPI in multiple sports despite wildly different dials. Makes one think.

Bartman

Well, it took the Liberty League women's soccer teams to humble the NESCAC teams in the NCAA tournament as William Smith beat the higher ranked Williams women 3-1 and Vassar beat the higher ranked Jumbos of Tufts 2-1. Now it is RPI football's turn to humble Trinity and render the NPI rankings useless. To me, this is more entertaining than the eventual final. The Sliderulers have my total support this Saturday. 
"I never graduated from Iowa, but I was only there for two terms - Truman's and Eisenhower's."
Alex Karras
"I have two weapons, my arms, my legs and my brain"
Michael Vick
"Nobody in football should be called a genius. A genius is a guy like Norman Einstein" Joe Theism

ICGrad

Quote from: Bartman on Yesterday at 07:10:38 AMWell, it took the Liberty League women's soccer teams to humble the NESCAC teams in the NCAA tournament as William Smith beat the higher ranked Williams women 3-1 and Vassar beat the higher ranked Jumbos of Tufts 2-1. Now it is RPI football's turn to humble Trinity and render the NPI rankings useless. To me, this is more entertaining than the eventual final. The Sliderulers have my total support this Saturday. 

Nice. Hadn't really been following women's soccer since Ithaca's season ended but great to see the LL out there representing so well...

Machiavelli

Quote from: IC798891 on November 15, 2026, 09:45:59 PMEndicott/Cortland is going to be a great QF matchup

I realize there's more than likely an element of trolling here, but maybe not. Is Cortland vs. Endicott a very plausible outcome? Absolutely. Would it be a great game? Sure. Is it an inevitable matchup? Not even close.

I know they're both NPI beasts or whatever. I know Endicott is touting this as its best team ever. I know Cortland just ran the table again. All fair points. But here's where I think people are getting ahead of themselves.

1. We literally know very little about the NESCAC teams, and there are some genuinely interesting matchups here.

  • Theoretically, Amherst should be able to beat Bridgewater. Hard stop. I wouldn't call it a certainty, but that's how I see that matchup.
  • Wesleyan vs. Springfield is fascinating. Beating Springfield is difficult, regardless of who you are. The lack of familiarity is a legitimate challenge for Wesleyan. Even with two weeks to prepare, there could be a significant adjustment period once that game starts. On the flip side, Wesleyan could absolutely eat them up. That's kind of the point: we don't know.
  • Trinity was widely viewed as the NESCAC's best team for much of the season, only to lose to Wesleyan this past weekend. Given that, I find it difficult to assume Trinity is somehow a class above RPI. Looking at that matchup more closely, I think RPI has a legitimate shot. The NESCAC message boards seem just as uncertain about these matchups as everyone else. Honestly, that's what makes this fun. We'll find out when they take the field.

2. If RPI gets past Trinity, I have no reservations about their ability to compete with Endicott.

Endicott is good. I get it. They're highly regarded, and they've earned that respect. But every season and every team is different. RPI has split its last two meetings with Endicott, and both were competitive games. I just don't personally view Endicott in the same category as the Mount Unions and North Centrals of the world. There's something to be said for having actually played a team, competed with them, and knowing you belong on the same field. That's not a small thing.

3. Cortland is good. They've been good for years. I get the Cortaca rivalry. But let's add a little perspective.


RPI just beat Ithaca on the road by four. Cortland beat Ithaca by seven at a neutral site. Obviously, it's not an apples-to-apples comparison, and I'm not suggesting common opponents are some definitive measuring stick. But these games happened in the last two weeks. It's at least a relevant data point, and it certainly doesn't suggest Cortland is operating on an entirely different level.

4. Hampden-Sydney vs. MMA is another interesting one.

I don't think particularly highly of MMA, but my familiarity with most of Hampden-Sydney's schedule is pretty limited. I honestly don't know what to make of that matchup. That said, I think Cortland probably gets through its first two games comfortably.

Look, RPI could absolutely be one-and-done. That's entirely possible. I'm not suggesting otherwise. But the way I see it, there's also a legitimate path to a Final Four run, particularly given how this bracket shook out.

The NESCAC unknowns are a huge part of this. Until these teams actually take the field against unfamiliar opponents, there's a lot of speculation masquerading as certainty. Maybe my perspective changes after next weekend. Maybe it doesn't.

But jumping straight to "Endicott/Cortland is going to be a great quarterfinal matchup" is getting a little ahead of ourselves.

Unless, of course, the objective is just to get a rise out of the RPI crowd. In which case, well played I guess.