FB: Liberty League

Started by admin, August 16, 2005, 04:58:34 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 37 Guests are viewing this topic.

Caz Bombers

Quote from: ICGrad on Yesterday at 08:35:07 AM
Quote from: Bartman on Yesterday at 07:10:38 AMWell, it took the Liberty League women's soccer teams to humble the NESCAC teams in the NCAA tournament as William Smith beat the higher ranked Williams women 3-1 and Vassar beat the higher ranked Jumbos of Tufts 2-1. Now it is RPI football's turn to humble Trinity and render the NPI rankings useless. To me, this is more entertaining than the eventual final. The Sliderulers have my total support this Saturday. 

Nice. Hadn't really been following women's soccer since Ithaca's season ended but great to see the LL out there representing so well...

Vassar gets another NESCAC shot on Saturday in the Don't Call It the Sweet 16 against Colby. WS faces Calvin on Friday.

IC798891

Quote from: Machiavelli on Yesterday at 08:43:52 AMI realize there's more than likely an element of trolling here, but maybe not.

Absolutely not.

The two met in the first round of the playoffs in 2023, and it came down to the last play, with Cortland stopping Endicott on a last second pass from the 11 yard line to win 23-17.

They met again in the first round in 2024, and it came down to the wire, with Cortland winning 17-9 and holding off Endicott in the 4th quarter.

They've beaten Hardin-Simmons and Hardin-Baylor in recent years. They've split with good Ithaca teams. They've beaten RPI. I think this is a program that has been building, and I think this is the year they break through. I think the rest of these NE schools aren't on their-- or Cortland's level.

As for Endicott/RPI, I'll throw in my two cents:

I think it's worth pointing out that against probably the three best teams they played this year, RPI's offense scored a total of 38 points. The defense is really good, but I don't think the LL has strong offensive teams, honestly.

IDC what the season PPG totals are. The numbers get inflated against disaster programs like Hilbert and Buff State and St Lawrence, but their limitations are shown elsewhere. The conference's single marquee OOC win, Hobart over Brockport, was all about the Statesman defense.

I certainly don't think Endicott's 80- and 90-burgers against the disasters of their own conference are indicative of anything either. But they also scored 28 points in a win over Hardin Baylor on the road. Which is a better offensive performance than anything our conference has done OOC.

The only people I troll are Union fans. Which Mach should be applauding

Bartman

Quote from: Machiavelli on Yesterday at 08:43:52 AM
Quote from: IC798891 on November 15, 2026, 09:45:59 PMEndicott/Cortland is going to be a great QF matchup

I realize there's more than likely an element of trolling here, but maybe not. Is Cortland vs. Endicott a very plausible outcome? Absolutely. Would it be a great game? Sure. Is it an inevitable matchup? Not even close.

I know they're both NPI beasts or whatever. I know Endicott is touting this as its best team ever. I know Cortland just ran the table again. All fair points. But here's where I think people are getting ahead of themselves.

1. We literally know very little about the NESCAC teams, and there are some genuinely interesting matchups here.

  • Theoretically, Amherst should be able to beat Bridgewater. Hard stop. I wouldn't call it a certainty, but that's how I see that matchup.
  • Wesleyan vs. Springfield is fascinating. Beating Springfield is difficult, regardless of who you are. The lack of familiarity is a legitimate challenge for Wesleyan. Even with two weeks to prepare, there could be a significant adjustment period once that game starts. On the flip side, Wesleyan could absolutely eat them up. That's kind of the point: we don't know.
  • Trinity was widely viewed as the NESCAC's best team for much of the season, only to lose to Wesleyan this past weekend. Given that, I find it difficult to assume Trinity is somehow a class above RPI. Looking at that matchup more closely, I think RPI has a legitimate shot. The NESCAC message boards seem just as uncertain about these matchups as everyone else. Honestly, that's what makes this fun. We'll find out when they take the field.

2. If RPI gets past Trinity, I have no reservations about their ability to compete with Endicott.

Endicott is good. I get it. They're highly regarded, and they've earned that respect. But every season and every team is different. RPI has split its last two meetings with Endicott, and both were competitive games. I just don't personally view Endicott in the same category as the Mount Unions and North Centrals of the world. There's something to be said for having actually played a team, competed with them, and knowing you belong on the same field. That's not a small thing.

3. Cortland is good. They've been good for years. I get the Cortaca rivalry. But let's add a little perspective.


RPI just beat Ithaca on the road by four. Cortland beat Ithaca by seven at a neutral site. Obviously, it's not an apples-to-apples comparison, and I'm not suggesting common opponents are some definitive measuring stick. But these games happened in the last two weeks. It's at least a relevant data point, and it certainly doesn't suggest Cortland is operating on an entirely different level.

4. Hampden-Sydney vs. MMA is another interesting one.

I don't think particularly highly of MMA, but my familiarity with most of Hampden-Sydney's schedule is pretty limited. I honestly don't know what to make of that matchup. That said, I think Cortland probably gets through its first two games comfortably.

Look, RPI could absolutely be one-and-done. That's entirely possible. I'm not suggesting otherwise. But the way I see it, there's also a legitimate path to a Final Four run, particularly given how this bracket shook out.

The NESCAC unknowns are a huge part of this. Until these teams actually take the field against unfamiliar opponents, there's a lot of speculation masquerading as certainty. Maybe my perspective changes after next weekend. Maybe it doesn't.

But jumping straight to "Endicott/Cortland is going to be a great quarterfinal matchup" is getting a little ahead of ourselves.

Unless, of course, the objective is just to get a rise out of the RPI crowd. In which case, well played I guess.
Thoughtful and analytical post. The Engineers have been here before and have successfully punched up. I'm thinking Trinity should look at the Hobart tape and be concerned that that RPI shows up. I don't see any of the inevitable, no way we win games , like the old days. RPI has a punchers chance all the way to the final four and I would love to see you get there. Your coach is a big asset and your football alums can pump up the team. Good luck.
"I never graduated from Iowa, but I was only there for two terms - Truman's and Eisenhower's."
Alex Karras
"I have two weapons, my arms, my legs and my brain"
Michael Vick
"Nobody in football should be called a genius. A genius is a guy like Norman Einstein" Joe Theism

Machiavelli

Under those circumstances, I agree Cortland vs. Endicott would be a fun matchup. I just wouldn't call it a foregone conclusion that we're getting there.

Look, RPI's performances against Utica and Brockport still make me a little ill when I go back and look at them. But I genuinely believe this team was still trying to find its identity, and I'd argue that's remained a work in progress throughout the season. That said, we've seen tangible improvement. The Hobart win felt like the turning point. They had several weeks to build on that, gain some confidence, and, unlike last year, managed to close out the season by beating two quality opponents. For what it's worth, the Union game should have been a shutout. That touchdown was at garbage time.

Endicott had some nice wins early in the season, but they haven't faced even a mediocre opponent since September 19. That's worth considering. I'm just not convinced Cortland and Endicott are operating on a completely different level from everyone else in this bracket. That doesn't mean I think either one won't ultimately win it all. I'm just not ready to hand them the bracket crown before a game has been played.

And then there's the NESCAC factor. Some believe those teams could be the top three in the bracket. Others think they're in for a rude awakening. My guess is the reality falls somewhere in between: they're probably right in the mix with much of the field. We just don't know yet, and that's precisely why these matchups are interesting.

Bartman

Hobart gets one more game playing Alfred State at the BOZ in the ECAC Clayton Chapman Bowl on 11/21. I would have preferred a St.John Fisher matchup( they are traveling to play Allegheny), but just happy to get one more home game for the Seniors and post season experience for the underclassmen. Go Bart!
"I never graduated from Iowa, but I was only there for two terms - Truman's and Eisenhower's."
Alex Karras
"I have two weapons, my arms, my legs and my brain"
Michael Vick
"Nobody in football should be called a genius. A genius is a guy like Norman Einstein" Joe Theism

Unionpalooza

I think RPI and Cortland are very much in the same weight class.  Sure, I don't know what to make of RPI's losses to Brockport and Utica any more than anyone else.  But based on the head to head with Union, RPI and Cortland seem pretty well matched.  Very similar games; Union had a little more success passing against RPI, but that was Luke Sheehan's 8th game as a starter, not his first. I think it mostly comes down to matchups, and I might like my odds with a senior-heavy, very disciplined RPI team against a Cortland team that tends to rely on explosive plays.

I think the NESCAC will be quite competitive in the bracket; they've got the size on the lines and enough high-skill guys to hang with most of the better D3 teams. Against the NCC and UW-Bratwursts of the world, not so much.

Machiavelli

Quote from: Unionpalooza on Yesterday at 12:58:03 PMI think RPI and Cortland are very much in the same weight class.  Sure, I don't know what to make of RPI's losses to Brockport and Utica any more than anyone else.  But based on the head to head with Union, RPI and Cortland seem pretty well matched.  Very similar games; Union had a little more success passing against RPI, but that was Luke Sheehan's 8th game as a starter, not his first. I think it mostly comes down to matchups, and I might like my odds with a senior-heavy, very disciplined RPI team against a Cortland team that tends to rely on explosive plays.

I think the NESCAC will be quite competitive in the bracket; they've got the size on the lines and enough high-skill guys to hang with most of the better D3 teams. Against the NCC and UW-Bratwursts of the world, not so much.

You seem pretty high on the NESCAC. You may be right. I honestly have no idea. Are these kids going to take their trust funds and run to mommy and daddy when they finally get punched in the mouth, or are they going to prove they're the immovable objects some people seem to think they are? Nobody knows until Saturday.

I see plenty of prep school backgrounds on the rosters. Interesting, sure, but I'm not sure what that tells us about football. They may come from very different walks of life than many of the kids at RPI, Springfield, or Bridgewater, but does any of that actually translate once the ball is kicked off? We'll find out.

Are some of these close games between NESCAC teams with vastly different records an indication that the conference is much more competitive top to bottom than the records suggest? Is there some unwritten gentlemen's agreement not to run up the score and hurt anyone's feelings? Did the Wesleyan and Trinity coaches have a secret society handshake to keep things close while making sure three NESCAC teams got into the tournament? Or is this all just a particularly well-packaged ball of overhyped mediocrity?

I'm genuinely curious to find out.

EH1971

Seeing a lot of "Cortland vs Endicott" banter with a little "NESCAC could be a factor" in the bracket. Quick question: who went into Cortland two years ago after Endicott lost there and dropped 40 on the defending champs? Who knocked out Cortland again last year? Who handily beat the 2nd and 3rd best teams in CNE this year, nevermind the bottom half of that dreadful conference? Pretty weird, given these facts, that "nobody else in New England is on Endicott or Cortland's level".

Unionpalooza

Quote from: EH1971 on Today at 08:22:51 AMSeeing a lot of "Cortland vs Endicott" banter with a little "NESCAC could be a factor" in the bracket. Quick question: who went into Cortland two years ago after Endicott lost there and dropped 40 on the defending champs? Who knocked out Cortland again last year? Who handily beat the 2nd and 3rd best teams in CNE this year, nevermind the bottom half of that dreadful conference? Pretty weird, given these facts, that "nobody else in New England is on Endicott or Cortland's level".

I dunno, maybe the same team that got pasted by both LL teams it played in 2023, and went 0-7 against the LL from 2017-2023? Maybe the one that had to return a blocked FG in the final minutes to beat powerhouse MIT this year, and eked out a 19-13 win against juggernaut WPI?

Listen, I think Springfield is a solid squad this year and can give anyone in the bracket a game, especially given their unusual offense. (I'd say the same for Utica.) But Cortland has a recent natty and is undefeated, and Endicott won its big boy game against UMHB (whereas Springfield got creamed in its one against UWP), plus Eastern and Muhlenberg.  You can spare us the Rodney Dangerfield impression.

Bartman

Quote from: EH1971 on Today at 08:22:51 AMSeeing a lot of "Cortland vs Endicott" banter with a little "NESCAC could be a factor" in the bracket. Quick question: who went into Cortland two years ago after Endicott lost there and dropped 40 on the defending champs? Who knocked out Cortland again last year? Who handily beat the 2nd and 3rd best teams in CNE this year, nevermind the bottom half of that dreadful conference? Pretty weird, given these facts, that "nobody else in New England is on Endicott or Cortland's level".
The fact is we don't really know how well Springfield will do against Wesleyan , I think it is a fascinating matchup. I'm rooting for Springfield, just because.....well, just because. The NESCAC is like  a group of homeschoolers showing up on a college campus for the first time.....they could be brilliant or it will just take them some time to adjust to the outside world. I know they have some great players given the recruiting competition in the region.As far as Cortland-Endicott inevitability, I did see Hobart scrimmage Cortland and saw their talent first hand . It is a notch above but not that much (see Cortaca). I love the bracket for local NE/Eastern team matchups and the fascination with the NESCAC team entrants.Plenty of great D3 football to be played.
"I never graduated from Iowa, but I was only there for two terms - Truman's and Eisenhower's."
Alex Karras
"I have two weapons, my arms, my legs and my brain"
Michael Vick
"Nobody in football should be called a genius. A genius is a guy like Norman Einstein" Joe Theism

EH1971

Not saying that Springfield is going to win anything, but the notion that "nobody in New England is on Endicott's level" is ridiculous. Springfield made it to the quarters two years ago and Endicott has one playoff win. Ever.

IC798891

Quote from: EH1971 on Today at 10:00:16 AMNot saying that Springfield is going to win anything, but the notion that "nobody in New England is on Endicott's level" is ridiculous. Springfield made it to the quarters two years ago and Endicott has one playoff win. Ever.

Is it 2024 or 2026? Asking for a friend

EH1971

I don't know. I wasn't the one who brought the 2017 LL results into the conversation.

IC798891

Quote from: EH1971 on Today at 10:39:20 AMI don't know. I wasn't the one who brought the 2017 LL results into the conversation.

Neither was I. I could care less what Springfield's historically done. Endicott has shown themselves to be a cut above this year, in my estimation, by beating a top 10 team on the road, while Springfield got blown out at home.

I think they will advance to the quarters and play Cortland. If I'm wrong and some other New England school beats both of them, I don't care. Ultimately, I don't even care if I'm right, and they obliterate everyone in their path the first few rounds.

I voiced an opinion, and if that hurts the feelings of a bunch of other NE-school supporters, the good news is I...don't really care


Patrick Coleman

Quote from: EH1971 on Today at 08:22:51 AMSeeing a lot of "Cortland vs Endicott" banter with a little "NESCAC could be a factor" in the bracket. Quick question: who went into Cortland two years ago after Endicott lost there and dropped 40 on the defending champs? Who knocked out Cortland again last year? Who handily beat the 2nd and 3rd best teams in CNE this year, nevermind the bottom half of that dreadful conference? Pretty weird, given these facts, that "nobody else in New England is on Endicott or Cortland's level".

Springfield has absolutely had Cortland's number two years in a row in the playoffs, but beating 5-5 Husson and 6-4 Western New England aren't really data points that are going to move the needle.

Publisher. Questions? Check our FAQ for D3f, D3h.
Quote from: old 40 on September 25, 2007, 08:23:57 PMLet's discuss (sports) in a positive way, sometimes kidding each other with no disrespect.