FB: Liberty League

Started by admin, August 16, 2005, 04:58:34 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

ajw5050 and 58 Guests are viewing this topic.

IC798891

Bummed, but also cannot be surprised.

His first year they had that excellent team that nearly went 10-0 -- their one loss to Hobart was a game that was 20-18 in the 4th, but they immediately crashed down after that and have been largely adrift since then. I compared them to an NPC in a video game, but this year they seemed to become bad, and you wonder if he just realized it was never gonna happen there.

Interested to see where he lands

stlawus

Quote from: Unionpalooza on November 18, 2026, 11:18:20 AM
Quote from: Bartman on November 18, 2026, 10:41:07 AM
Quote from: stlawus on November 18, 2026, 10:18:17 AMPuckhaber has stepped down from the head coaching position at SLU.
Not totally surprising. I have no close connection to current SLU football, but my impression was that he is a good coach but had recruiting issues in the last decade, which often points to the college support of the program, but I have no knowledge. That said, it is the first away game I played in and they had a really good punter/receiver former NYGiant Dave Jennings Best of luck to the program.

Bummer.  I also have no special knowledge but recent SLU teams have always seemed to me play hard and smart, with talent (and esp. depth of talent) the real problem. SLU is an impossible place to recruit well without serious institutional support in admissions and financial aid, so I have to think their problem is the administration, not the coach. Hopefully he lands at a school that gives him the resources to succeed.

Will never happen, but I would love to see him as OC at Union.  We could use an O line dude behind the offensive wheel.

From what I've gathered he's leaving the coaching ranks.

Unionpalooza

Quote from: stlawus on November 18, 2026, 11:48:42 AM
Quote from: Unionpalooza on November 18, 2026, 11:18:20 AM
Quote from: Bartman on November 18, 2026, 10:41:07 AM
Quote from: stlawus on November 18, 2026, 10:18:17 AMPuckhaber has stepped down from the head coaching position at SLU.
Not totally surprising. I have no close connection to current SLU football, but my impression was that he is a good coach but had recruiting issues in the last decade, which often points to the college support of the program, but I have no knowledge. That said, it is the first away game I played in and they had a really good punter/receiver former NYGiant Dave Jennings Best of luck to the program.

Bummer.  I also have no special knowledge but recent SLU teams have always seemed to me play hard and smart, with talent (and esp. depth of talent) the real problem. SLU is an impossible place to recruit well without serious institutional support in admissions and financial aid, so I have to think their problem is the administration, not the coach. Hopefully he lands at a school that gives him the resources to succeed.

Will never happen, but I would love to see him as OC at Union.  We could use an O line dude behind the offensive wheel.

From what I've gathered he's leaving the coaching ranks.

Interesting, SUNY Maritime coach (Andrew Dresner) also stepped down today, leaving the ranks.  Former OC at Holy Cross, Maine and Stony Brook.  Being a D3 HC is an increasingly rough gig.

IC798891

The thing that, I suspect, is hardest about D3 is that the hours and workload probably don't change all that much from the upper levels, but the pay isn't exactly life changing.

Burnout is a feature of coaching football, not a big. At my last job, I worked for what would essentially be called a trade magazine for coaches, and we did a lot of stories on how to avoid burnout in the profession. I interviewed a lot of coaches, and it was staggering how the advice showed just how impossible it was.

One coach was like "I carve two hours a week, on my calendar, to do whatever I want." Another one was like "We don't start a new task on the weekends after 10 p.m." The talk wasn't about how to avoid working 70-80 hour weeks, but how to avoid 100-hour weeks.

Eighty hour weeks and constant travel is probably at least a begrudging tradeoff when you're making D1 type money. But I'm guessing there are less time consuming ways to make 80-100K

Jonny Utah

#58084
Ithaca Quarterback Michael Reed entering the transfer portal where he can play a 5th year in d2 or D1.

Maybe Hilbert can go D2 and just take every LL senior all star (and E8) as 5th year players and see how they do against national competition....

Machiavelli

Quote from: Jonny Utah on November 18, 2026, 08:35:20 PMIthaca Quarterback Michael Reed entering the transfer portal where he can play a 5th year in d2 or D1.

Maybe Hilbert can go D2 and just take every LL senior all star (and E8) as 5th year players and see how they do against national competition....

Hilbert will be so dope. How's their MBA program?

Machiavelli

I'm sorry, but RPI's turning point was not:

"The 14–10 win at Ithaca. Arthur Hrycak's fourth-down sack stopped Ithaca from adding to its lead in the third quarter, and Justin McCormack later hit Grayson Hunter for the go-ahead touchdown. The defense shut out the Bombers in the second half, and RPI left with its first Liberty League title since 2021 and the automatic playoff bid."

RPI had their asses handed to them for two straight weeks. Then they went out and dismantled Hobart, a team that had beaten up Brockport and lost a nail-biter to Utica. I'd nearly given up on their season at that point. The Hobart game changed everything.

Since then, they've won seven straight by a combined score of 306–39. They should have beaten Ithaca and Union last year, but those games weren't the turning point of this season. Hobart was. That's where this team changed.

Patrick Coleman

Quote from: Machiavelli on November 18, 2026, 09:09:21 PMI'm sorry, but RPI's turning point was not:

"The 14–10 win at Ithaca. Arthur Hrycak's fourth-down sack stopped Ithaca from adding to its lead in the third quarter, and Justin McCormack later hit Grayson Hunter for the go-ahead touchdown. The defense shut out the Bombers in the second half, and RPI left with its first Liberty League title since 2021 and the automatic playoff bid."

RPI had their asses handed to them for two straight weeks. Then they went out and dismantled Hobart, a team that had beaten up Brockport and lost a nail-biter to Utica. I'd nearly given up on their season at that point. The Hobart game changed everything.

Since then, they've won seven straight by a combined score of 306–39. They should have beaten Ithaca and Union last year, but those games weren't the turning point of this season. Hobart was. That's where this team changed.

I'll add it to the list of things you don't like.

The guy who I tabbed for this one has seen six RPI games but your mileage may vary.
Publisher. Questions? Check our FAQ for D3f, D3h.
Quote from: old 40 on September 25, 2007, 08:23:57 PMLet's discuss (sports) in a positive way, sometimes kidding each other with no disrespect.

Machiavelli

Sorry for making discussion on a message board. Regardless, your guy is wrong. RPI's 'turning point' was not 2 weeks ago.

'Add it to the list things you don't like.' Pat, most boards around here are completely flat. Is that what you're going for with a response like that?

Jesus H. You know I'm right. Just go with it man. Your 'guy' will be ok if you agree with me. He had a nice write up. But he missed the mark here.

Patrick Coleman

Quote from: Machiavelli on November 18, 2026, 09:22:46 PMSorry for making discussion on a message board.

Congrats on rebranding "perennially complaining" as "making discussion."
Publisher. Questions? Check our FAQ for D3f, D3h.
Quote from: old 40 on September 25, 2007, 08:23:57 PMLet's discuss (sports) in a positive way, sometimes kidding each other with no disrespect.

Machiavelli

Quote from: Patrick Coleman on November 18, 2026, 11:25:27 PM
Quote from: Machiavelli on November 18, 2026, 09:22:46 PMSorry for making discussion on a message board.

Congrats on rebranding "perennially complaining" as "making discussion."

Grumpy. Pants. McGee.

Bartman

Quote from: Machiavelli on November 18, 2026, 09:09:21 PMI'm sorry, but RPI's turning point was not:

"The 14–10 win at Ithaca. Arthur Hrycak's fourth-down sack stopped Ithaca from adding to its lead in the third quarter, and Justin McCormack later hit Grayson Hunter for the go-ahead touchdown. The defense shut out the Bombers in the second half, and RPI left with its first Liberty League title since 2021 and the automatic playoff bid."

RPI had their asses handed to them for two straight weeks. Then they went out and dismantled Hobart, a team that had beaten up Brockport and lost a nail-biter to Utica. I'd nearly given up on their season at that point. The Hobart game changed everything.

Since then, they've won seven straight by a combined score of 306–39. They should have beaten Ithaca and Union last year, but those games weren't the turning point of this season. Hobart was. That's where this team changed.
Having been the victim of the RPI turning point against Hobart, I have to agree with Mach. I was licking my chops going into the RPI game given the performances by both teams to that point, but RPI was totally focused and turned two seasons around,RPI for the better and Hobart for worse.
"I never graduated from Iowa, but I was only there for two terms - Truman's and Eisenhower's."
Alex Karras
"I have two weapons, my arms, my legs and my brain"
Michael Vick
"Nobody in football should be called a genius. A genius is a guy like Norman Einstein" Joe Theism

Machiavelli

Bartman, you see it the right way. Look, I don't really care what that writeup says. I suppose we're splitting hairs here, but everyone should know when RPI's season actually turned around. I think everyone here probably agrees.

Through three games, RPI was sitting at 1-2, with a 59-90 PF/PA and two blowout losses. It genuinely felt like a "maybe next year" kind of season. I actually picked Hobart to beat them that week. Three games in, Hobart looked like a pretty legitimate candidate to win the Liberty League.

Then something entirely unexpected happened.

This wasn't a nail-biting, last-second, one-point win against Hobart. RPI completely undressed them. Hobart didn't score until 3:21 remaining in the fourth quarter. The defense finally woke up, the offense found some consistency, and the trajectory of the season changed.

RPI went on to win seven straight, outscoring opponents 306-39.

So yeah, maybe I'm a perennial complainer. But all I did was point out that they had the wrong game identified as the actual turning point. There's a pretty significant difference.

Machiavelli

Interesting quote from the Trinity coach regarding game film:

'There are disadvantages and advantages to only getting three films on a team. You're not overwhelmed with too much info, but two of the last three RPI games weren't close games. Our three films they got were the gauntlet we had to go through at the end of the year, which gives them three competitive games to watch.'

I mean sure, St. Lawrence is in there...But Ithaca and Union to end the year is the same gauntlet, RPI just happened to beat Union handily. One of Trinity's last 3 was against 4-5 Middlebury. They won by 3. Not sure if that qualifies as the 'gauntlet', or if you were just lucky to get the win.

Bartman

The more you read   8-) 8-) about the RPI- Trinity matchup the more I can't wait for the game. At least the NESCAC has two other teams in the dance but the LL just has the Sliderulers. So Mach,  your team better not F this up.
"I never graduated from Iowa, but I was only there for two terms - Truman's and Eisenhower's."
Alex Karras
"I have two weapons, my arms, my legs and my brain"
Michael Vick
"Nobody in football should be called a genius. A genius is a guy like Norman Einstein" Joe Theism