FB: Liberty League

Started by admin, August 16, 2005, 04:58:34 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 36 Guests are viewing this topic.

Bartman

NESCAC board seems pretty realistic, showing respect for RPI. D3 Football crowd seems fairly certain  the lone LL entrant will be set aside. These are relevant rating comparison:
                  NPI.        Massey.        Hansen
Bantams.          26.          22.            52

Sliderulers.      43.          37.            30

Honestly, I think Hansen's process/formula is better than NPI or Massey, so although no one can really be certain with no common opponents, his data is very comprehensive. You'll know in the first quarter whether Kayden White rips through the Bantams or if it is "cloud of dust" dragged down by the Bantam Dline/LB corps. If the RPI Oline is effective on the run, the passing game opens up as Isernia and his OC scramble the plays. On defense the trenches will be brutal as both teams have talent. The Trinity QB options offer a variety of skills and they can be effective and challenge the RPI DBs, but RPI has shown the can pick off passes with 17 this season. Neither team should dominate the other for the entire game, and if it comes to post season experience, my money is on Isernia to adapt as the game unfolds.                      I'm calling it now; RPI 27-Trinity 24. 
"I never graduated from Iowa, but I was only there for two terms - Truman's and Eisenhower's."
Alex Karras
"I have two weapons, my arms, my legs and my brain"
Michael Vick
"Nobody in football should be called a genius. A genius is a guy like Norman Einstein" Joe Theism

Unionpalooza

Out of curiosity I zipped through the RPI/Brockport game on YouTube. Weirdest game ever.

RPI's safeties blow the coverage on a long bomb to give up the first TD, then they (along with the OLB) absurdly overpursue the RB and give up a homerun carry on the next series.

Kayden White rushes for 40 yards on three carries on RPI's first series, then gets all of two carries for the remaing 27 minutes of the first half.

Down 14-7 early with first and goal from the Brockport 3, with Kayden White in the backfield, RPI throws three straight incompletions.

On the late 2Q bomb that puts RPI down 28-10, three separate members of the RPI secondary miss tackles in the course of four seconds.

Most importantly, RPI trots out a third-string QB in his first start, and has him throw 17 passes and run the ball 12 times in the first six drives before benching him for McCormick after his second pick.

With rationale playcalling and just a single safety playing like they weren't drinking all night with Billy Bob from Varsity Blues, I think that game goes very, very differently.

IC798891

They clearly cleaned up a lot after both the Utica and Brockport games. Lest we forget, Szalkowski went 29-for-38 for 402 yards and two scores against their secondary.

Given how both of those offenses fell flat against the best team they face (Cortland) and had a 14-9 rock fight against each other, I don't think their results against RPI were indicative of their own prowess, just two disaster classes back to back.

Machiavelli

#58113
After erroneously picking St. Lawrence to upset Rochester, I finished the regular season at 44-7. I only wish I could pull off those #s on DraftKings. I'm gonna go ahead and pick the Cortland Bracket here and call it a day. Let's see how this goes...

Mach's Complaint-Free Postseason Round 1 Picks

Bridgewater St. - 17
Amherst - 20
This was actually tougher to pick than I thought. Just full on theoretically, I think Amherst should win this game. But Bridgewater can put up some points, though against putrid competition. Amherst looks like they play a lot of lower-ish scoring rock fights. Was Amherst just really lucky this year? They won 7 games by 10 or less and 4 by 6 or less, with their 1 loss by 3. I think Bridgewater actually hangs in a bit, but Amherst grinds it out and kicks a field goal to win it.

RPI - 31
Trinity - 21
I know the d3 dot com group won't like this pick very much, but as the week has gone on, I've felt more confident in this matchup for RPI and I think there's a really solid chance they surprise. I don't fear the unknown of the speed and athleticism of Trinity. I think RPI can keep up there and are quite fast and athletic themselves. I think the biggest question mark is on the line of scrimmage. If RPI struggles at the line on both sides of the ball, that will spell trouble. I'm not saying that is going to happen, but that is the biggest worry factor I have because we don't know. Trinity's last 4 matchups have been decided by 7 or less. RPI's only close game this year was Ithaca. Trinity might have a little more experience in a tight game, but I think RPI gets started early and often as the shock factor wears off for Trinity. They make a late comeback, and RPI slams the door in the 4th quarter.

There it is. Call me crazy.

ICGrad

Quote from: Machiavelli on Today at 10:02:33 AMI know the d3.com

Dammit, Mach. D3football.com.

D3.com is, as I now know thanks to you, "The internet's biggest asset class Now liquid and agent-ready" (Missing periods in source; don't blame me for grammatical shenanigans).

ICGrad

Quote from: Jonny Utah on November 18, 2026, 08:35:20 PMIthaca Quarterback Michael Reed entering the transfer portal where he can play a 5th year in d2 or D1.

Maybe Hilbert can go D2 and just take every LL senior all star (and E8) as 5th year players and see how they do against national competition....

Sorry...missed this when it was posted.

Does he have to go to D2 or D1? Can players not play a 5th season in D3?

Machiavelli

Quote from: ICGrad on Today at 10:21:27 AM
Quote from: Machiavelli on Today at 10:02:33 AMI know the d3.com

Dammit, Mach. D3football.com.

D3.com is, as I now know thanks to you, "The internet's biggest asset class Now liquid and agent-ready" (Missing periods in source; don't blame me for grammatical shenanigans).

Edited to d3 dot com. Reading that description is confusing on a several levels. LOL

Patrick Coleman

Quote from: ICGrad on Today at 10:23:33 AM
Quote from: Jonny Utah on November 18, 2026, 08:35:20 PMIthaca Quarterback Michael Reed entering the transfer portal where he can play a 5th year in d2 or D1.

Maybe Hilbert can go D2 and just take every LL senior all star (and E8) as 5th year players and see how they do against national competition....

Sorry...missed this when it was posted.

Does he have to go to D2 or D1? Can players not play a 5th season in D3?

Not unless he has a medical hardship season he can use. Currently D-III has not approved a fifth season, but it does seem like it will be voted on at the NCAA convention in January.
Publisher. Questions? Check our FAQ for D3f, D3h.
Quote from: old 40 on September 25, 2007, 08:23:57 PMLet's discuss (sports) in a positive way, sometimes kidding each other with no disrespect.

Unionpalooza

Quote from: Patrick Coleman on Today at 11:02:34 AM
Quote from: ICGrad on Today at 10:23:33 AM
Quote from: Jonny Utah on November 18, 2026, 08:35:20 PMIthaca Quarterback Michael Reed entering the transfer portal where he can play a 5th year in d2 or D1.

Maybe Hilbert can go D2 and just take every LL senior all star (and E8) as 5th year players and see how they do against national competition....

Sorry...missed this when it was posted.

Does he have to go to D2 or D1? Can players not play a 5th season in D3?

Not unless he has a medical hardship season he can use. Currently D-III has not approved a fifth season, but it does seem like it will be voted on at the NCAA convention in January.


For those interested in the 5-year eligibility issue, this recent report from the NCAA's DIII Analysis Working Group is pretty interesting. 

The DIII Management Council is opposed to moving D3 to five years at this time; the DIII President's Council has decided to take no position so far, though they've generally suggested that the full D3 membership should refer it for further study rather than approve or disapprove it in January.  They have one more meeting before the January membership vote.  There has been some interesting jockeying about whether a simple majority or a super majority will be required, but it appears that it will be the former.  (The fact that the DIII President's Council didn't insist on a super-majority suggests to me that they are somewhat confident that the full membership will refer it for further study rather than approve it.).

The general consensus is that the membership is split pretty close to 50/50.  For comparison, the full membership voted 60/40 against adding a redshirt year to D3 last year; that was obviously before D1/2 moved to five years.

If it's a close vote and the membership decides to move to five years, no one should underestimate the odds that a real movement to break D3 into two develops. There are a lot of D3 schools that don't want and/or can't accommodate a five-year athlete model (e.g., no real grad programs), and have no interest in competing against programs stacked with super-seniors.

Patrick Coleman

Quote from: ICGrad on Today at 10:21:27 AM
Quote from: Machiavelli on Today at 10:02:33 AMI know the d3.com

Dammit, Mach. D3football.com.

D3.com is, as I now know thanks to you, "The internet's biggest asset class Now liquid and agent-ready" (Missing periods in source; don't blame me for grammatical shenanigans).

We do have D3fb.com if that's helpful to write as short-hand.

I had the same questions about both of those games. I also agree that the Amherst game will be lower scoring -- I think they both will, actually.
Publisher. Questions? Check our FAQ for D3f, D3h.
Quote from: old 40 on September 25, 2007, 08:23:57 PMLet's discuss (sports) in a positive way, sometimes kidding each other with no disrespect.

Bartman

Quote from: Unionpalooza on Today at 11:28:56 AM
Quote from: Patrick Coleman on Today at 11:02:34 AM
Quote from: ICGrad on Today at 10:23:33 AM
Quote from: Jonny Utah on November 18, 2026, 08:35:20 PMIthaca Quarterback Michael Reed entering the transfer portal where he can play a 5th year in d2 or D1.

Maybe Hilbert can go D2 and just take every LL senior all star (and E8) as 5th year players and see how they do against national competition....

Sorry...missed this when it was posted.

Does he have to go to D2 or D1? Can players not play a 5th season in D3?

Not unless he has a medical hardship season he can use. Currently D-III has not approved a fifth season, but it does seem like it will be voted on at the NCAA convention in January.


For those interested in the 5-year eligibility issue, this recent report from the NCAA's DIII Analysis Working Group is pretty interesting. 

The DIII Management Council is opposed to moving D3 to five years at this time; the DIII President's Council has decided to take no position so far, though they've generally suggested that the full D3 membership should refer it for further study rather than approve or disapprove it in January.  They have one more meeting before the January membership vote.  There has been some interesting jockeying about whether a simple majority or a super majority will be required, but it appears that it will be the former.  (The fact that the DIII President's Council didn't insist on a super-majority suggests to me that they are somewhat confident that the full membership will refer it for further study rather than approve it.).

The general consensus is that the membership is split pretty close to 50/50.  For comparison, the full membership voted 60/40 against adding a redshirt year to D3 last year; that was obviously before D1/2 moved to five years.

If it's a close vote and the membership decides to move to five years, no one should underestimate the odds that a real movement to break D3 into two develops. There are a lot of D3 schools that don't want and/or can't accommodate a five-year athlete model (e.g., no real grad programs), and have no interest in competing against programs stacked with super-seniors.

Thinking about this for D3, I'm good with the old "redshirt " year, but approving a fifth year seems complicated for D3. An inventory of Fifth year seniors for schools with a broad selection of graduate programs seems unfair, so I could see a split that would be very unfortunate. Also, schools with on-line graduate programs can be very flexible in extending a players career, even if they don't finish the program after the Fall of their fifth year.
D3 loves football programs for the tuition revenue, but this seems a bridge too far for D3, in my opinion.
"I never graduated from Iowa, but I was only there for two terms - Truman's and Eisenhower's."
Alex Karras
"I have two weapons, my arms, my legs and my brain"
Michael Vick
"Nobody in football should be called a genius. A genius is a guy like Norman Einstein" Joe Theism

Jonny Utah

My take on RPI after the IC game:

1.  Kayden White needs to be stopped.  I don't think RPI has much in the passing game that is dangerous, but they have enough to make you pay if you sell out too much against the run.  Their offense is their weakness, but they have some good coaches who seem to gameplan great scheme and plays when they need them. 

2.  Their defense is what shines.  They make you run it.  They are 30th in the country in defensive rushing but they don't load the box.  They remind me of the 07-08 Giants who evolved into one of the top defenses in the league, rushing 4 and dropping everyone else, daring you to complete a pass while they put very good pressure on the QB.  RPI is tied for 12th nationally in sacks, averaging 3.2 sacks per game.  They are 9th nationally in tackles for loss with 8.5 TFL per game.  Teams are under 30% on 3rd down vs RPI, they have four pick 6s (tied for 2nd nationally) and  overall are 12th in the nation in scoring defense.

I saw some Trinity/Nescac posters talking about size and how that may impact anything.  I do not believe it does. Ithaca has had the larger olines in the league the past few years but if you see them up close, they are more Mass than Muscle and that doesn't always give you the advantage in the trenches.  They were unable to move the ball vs RPI with any sort of consistency and that ultimately determined the game imo. 

Wish I could head down there for this game but I will be raking leaves and all that fun stuff.