FB: Liberty League

Started by admin, August 16, 2005, 04:58:34 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Oline89 and 126 Guests are viewing this topic.

Bartman

#58140
Condolences to the Engineers on the loss today. I was at the Hobart-Alfred State Bowl game and was watching the live stats.  I said if Kayden White struggled, RPI would likely lose and they did. Trinity has a very strong defense that can keep it in the game against Endicott next week.  We know RPI is a resilient team and they were today having a chance to come from behind with 2 minutes left. This was the LL vs NESCAC champs and although a tip of the hat to Trinity, they  did not win convincingly in the score , but they sure shut down the RPI run game. The RPI passing game was surprisingly unproductive , so it was amazing RPI was still in the game at the end. My first impression( without actually eyeballing the action) is that the top LL teams and the top NESCAC teams would have some very competitive games if they scheduled each other. It is unlikely that Trinity will prevail against Endicott and I think Cortland should dispose of Amherst. Not sure about Wesleyan and that Springfield offense .It will be very interesting next week.
   As far as Hobart ,they had a great day against a fairly good team in Alfred State , despite the 63-14 score. It was a day of ALL-Time Hobart records being broken as EJ Taylor set the most TDs in a season and the season scoring record. Zeshan Dixon set the most Interceptions All-Time record . It was a beautiful day, and although I wish we had made the NCAA tournament, the team looks like next year will be a good one. When EJ wasn't running , Aidan Conrath was passing with the most accuracy since Shane Sweeney and I think he will step up to be the best QB in the LL next year.( No Interceptions the entire season (evidencing his accuracy). Despite losing EJ, our RB position looks like it will be efficient with Tristen Reynolds returning and the receiving corp is strong. Our defense will lose a couple of very good Seniors but the vast majority of the starters will be back. Both lines will be returning some strong performers with more experience. I am very optimistic for the 2027 season
"I never graduated from Iowa, but I was only there for two terms - Truman's and Eisenhower's."
Alex Karras
"I have two weapons, my arms, my legs and my brain"
Michael Vick
"Nobody in football should be called a genius. A genius is a guy like Norman Einstein" Joe Theism

IC798891

#58141
"We're being hurt because Buff State and Hilbert are in our conference!" "The NPI overrated the NESCAC"

Then in the playoffs, the LL champion, with the conference's co-offensive player of year at running back, produces zero first downs on the ground, but one safety -- which wasn't even the only safety they allowed!

And we're sitting here yakking about "The better team lost" talking about dropped passes and the yips.

The conference champion played three OOC opponents with winning records. They went 0-3 and the offense scored 14, 10, 10 points in the three games. The conference runner up led for a combined  zero minutes and zero seconds in their two toughest OOC games. The defending conference champion's lone OOC win came against a 1-9, last place finisher.

The conference had eleven weeks to prove itself, and the single decent result they managed to produce was their third place team beating the 3rd place team in the E8.

Every time the LL had a chance to prove themselves, they lost. And all the excuses in the world aren't going to change that. They simply weren't good

Unionpalooza

Quote from: IC798891 on Today at 08:51:34 AM"We're being hurt because Buff State and Hilbert are in our conference!" "The NPI overrated the NESCAC"

Then in the playoffs, the LL champion, with the conference's co-offensive player of year at running back, produces zero first downs on the ground, but one safety -- which wasn't even the only safety they allowed!

And we're sitting here yakking about "The better team lost" talking about dropped passes and the yips.

The conference champion played three OOC opponents with winning records. They went 0-3 and the offense scored 14, 10, 10 points in the three games. The conference runner up led for a combined  zero minutes and zero seconds in their two toughest OOC games. The defending conference champion's lone OOC win came against a 1-9, last place finisher.

The conference had eleven weeks to prove itself, and the single decent result they managed to produce was their third place team beating the 3rd place team in the E8.

Every time the LL had a chance to prove themselves, they lost. And all the excuses in the world aren't going to change that. They simply weren't good

On the big stage, mediocre QB play makes for mediocre teams. I don't see anyone in the league making much noise nationally, or even regionally, until they find a stud gunslinger. That's just how D3 works now.

Ice Bear

Quote from: IC798891 on Today at 08:51:34 AM"We're being hurt because Buff State and Hilbert are in our conference!" "The NPI overrated the NESCAC"

Then in the playoffs, the LL champion, with the conference's co-offensive player of year at running back, produces zero first downs on the ground, but one safety -- which wasn't even the only safety they allowed!

And we're sitting here yakking about "The better team lost" talking about dropped passes and the yips.

The conference champion played three OOC opponents with winning records. They went 0-3 and the offense scored 14, 10, 10 points in the three games. The conference runner up led for a combined  zero minutes and zero seconds in their two toughest OOC games. The defending conference champion's lone OOC win came against a 1-9, last place finisher.

The conference had eleven weeks to prove itself, and the single decent result they managed to produce was their third place team beating the 3rd place team in the E8.

Every time the LL had a chance to prove themselves, they lost. And all the excuses in the world aren't going to change that. They simply weren't good

I have to agree with this IC, wholeheartedly.
A long time fan of DIII Football!

ICGrad

Quote from: IC798891 on Today at 08:51:34 AM"We're being hurt because Buff State and Hilbert are in our conference!" "The NPI overrated the NESCAC"

Both of these are true.

Well, the first is true. As far as the second is concerned, the NPI gave the NESCAC an unfair advantage over other teams when it came to selection of at-large bids. Not sure if the NPI overrated the conference; I think that still remains to be seen. But if the NESCAC continues to refuse to play out-of-conference games, they should be prohibited from earning at-large bids.

That said, much of what you go on to say is also true. The LL has had back-to-back uncharacteristically down seasons. They have gone from being a conference that is perennially ranked in the top 10 - and often in the top 5, as they were in 2024 - on sites like Massey, and a conference that could reasonably expect to get two teams in the playoffs at least every few years, to being a conference barely clinging to the top 20 in the Massey ratings (of 33 conference!). So they've dropped from being a near elite-level conference to being below-average, in the span of a couple of years.

Yes, some of that is the addition of Hilbert, who add absolutely nothing to the conference and who would struggle (and have) to compete with JV squads.

But clearly overall quality has dropped in the LL as well. Here's hoping this is just a blip and the LL will rebound in coming seasons.

Some suggested the difference, at least vis-a-vias the E8 (where 70% of our out-of-conference games - and hence much of that Massey Strength-of-Confernce ranking - comes from, might be the relative lack of JV programs in the Liberty League. This certainly makes sense. No JV means fewer players in the pipeline and fewer development opportunities for young players. Maybe more LL schools look at adding JV programs back?

Bartman

I don't think I want to over analyze RPI's loss to Trinity. Although they were stopped cold by the Trinity DLine , somehow they were ahead in the fourth quarter and still had a chance to pull it out. That doesn't sound like Trinity dominated them, despite the yardage differential in the game.
We just had a down year in the LL and , yes,we are burdened by a bad Buffalo State team and a Hilbert high school team (it seems fitting that their home games were played at a high school field), but everyone seemed to take a step backwards in 2026. 
All LL teams need to get better next year , finish a successful Freshman recruiting Class with some good talent and  excel in their OOC games in 2007. Let's get out of this hole. 
"I never graduated from Iowa, but I was only there for two terms - Truman's and Eisenhower's."
Alex Karras
"I have two weapons, my arms, my legs and my brain"
Michael Vick
"Nobody in football should be called a genius. A genius is a guy like Norman Einstein" Joe Theism