NESCAC

Started by LaPaz, September 11, 2011, 05:54:52 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 6 Guests are viewing this topic.

MunnyTim

Quote from: Bucket on November 11, 2026, 01:49:49 PM
Quote from: nescac1 on November 11, 2026, 11:54:03 AMAll conference teams out.  Stunned that Williams, the top overall seed in the NCAA tourney, only has one all-league player (meanwhile Trinity has three?). In particular, I don't understand how Jake Farmer, who was a rock all year, didn't make it at D.  The Ephs are very balanced so I understand having only one (well-deserving) offensive player, but Darrell at GK, Ruehlmann at F, and Appleton at ROTY were other guys who at least warranted consideration. 

Or, if the talent really was so deficient relative to say Bowdoin (five all league players) maybe the coaching staff should have been honored! 

Conn's an even better comparison: Player of the Year, Defensive Player of the Year, 3 first-team selections, and 5 total—all to finish...4th?

Just chiming in that Conn was two second half disallowed goals (one against Bates, the other against Bowdoin) from finishing top of the table this year...  Top five were within four points of each other.  One or two bounces (or calls) and any of those top 5 could have finished first in the regular season.

Sandon Mibut

NESCAC results in non-conference play totals 42-1-8.

Colby: 3-0-2
Trinity: 4-0-0
Bates: 3-1-1
Wesleyan: 4-0-1
Amherst: 5-0-0
Hamilton: 3-0-1
Bowdoin: 3-0-2
Tufts: 4-0-1
Conn: 5-0-0
Midd: 4-0-0
Williams: 4-0-0

The "bottom half" of NESCAC (ranks 6-11) are 23-1-4 in non-conference games.

And bottom 3 are 10-1-3. If one team had an entire season that matches the opponents & results of these 3 non-conference schedules (Bates, Trinity, Colby), that hypothetical team would have an NPI of 56.4 for an NPI rank of #31.

Opponents of Bates, Trinity and Colby:
#25 loss 48.1
#31 tie 56.4 (half loss + half win)
#85 win 60.5
#143 win 59.1
#146 win 59.0
#161 win 58.4
#161 tie 25.5 (half loss / throwaway the half win)
#164 win 58.3
#174 win 58.2
#202 win 57.7
#205 tie 25.1 (half loss / throwaway the half win)
#275 win 55.8
#288 win 55.4
#288 win 55.4

10.5 wins, 2.5 losses
* IDK jack about soccer. I cheer for Tufts, Middlebury and Upstate NY teams and I enjoy crunching numbers

wesleyansuperfan20

Quote from: MunnyTim on November 11, 2026, 04:02:23 PM
Quote from: Bucket on November 11, 2026, 01:49:49 PM
Quote from: nescac1 on November 11, 2026, 11:54:03 AMAll conference teams out.  Stunned that Williams, the top overall seed in the NCAA tourney, only has one all-league player (meanwhile Trinity has three?). In particular, I don't understand how Jake Farmer, who was a rock all year, didn't make it at D.  The Ephs are very balanced so I understand having only one (well-deserving) offensive player, but Darrell at GK, Ruehlmann at F, and Appleton at ROTY were other guys who at least warranted consideration. 

Or, if the talent really was so deficient relative to say Bowdoin (five all league players) maybe the coaching staff should have been honored! 

Conn's an even better comparison: Player of the Year, Defensive Player of the Year, 3 first-team selections, and 5 total—all to finish...4th?

Just chiming in that Conn was two second half disallowed goals (one against Bates, the other against Bowdoin) from finishing top of the table this year...  Top five were within four points of each other.  One or two bounces (or calls) and any of those top 5 could have finished first in the regular season.

I'd agree with Bucket and nescac1. Though I'm biased towards Wes, I'm a bit surprised at the number of selections this year given their position in the table and a first round loss in the NESCAC playoffs... and yet, they had multiple honorees across the teams. That's not to say the players aren't deserving... but should Williams not have more?

Another one that stuck out was the Co-Coaching Staff of the Year selections, awarded to Hamilton and Middlebury. I can see the argument for Hamilton - that's a team that finished at the bottom of the table last season, missing out on playoffs, who now goes into the NCAA Tournament as a top 10 team in the country with a NESCAC-semifinal loss in penalties to the reigning national champions. But, Middlebury? Don't get me wrong, it's hard to overlook their success in recent years, but that's precisely my point. Middlebury, a team usually at the top of the conference, lost in 90' in the NESCAC quarterfinals. Does this really make their staff deserving of this award? It feels like the committee just couldn't handle not giving something to Midd.

Bucket

Quote from: wesleyansuperfan20 on November 12, 2026, 03:16:08 PM
Quote from: MunnyTim on November 11, 2026, 04:02:23 PM
Quote from: Bucket on November 11, 2026, 01:49:49 PM
Quote from: nescac1 on November 11, 2026, 11:54:03 AMAll conference teams out.  Stunned that Williams, the top overall seed in the NCAA tourney, only has one all-league player (meanwhile Trinity has three?). In particular, I don't understand how Jake Farmer, who was a rock all year, didn't make it at D.  The Ephs are very balanced so I understand having only one (well-deserving) offensive player, but Darrell at GK, Ruehlmann at F, and Appleton at ROTY were other guys who at least warranted consideration. 

Or, if the talent really was so deficient relative to say Bowdoin (five all league players) maybe the coaching staff should have been honored! 

Conn's an even better comparison: Player of the Year, Defensive Player of the Year, 3 first-team selections, and 5 total—all to finish...4th?

Just chiming in that Conn was two second half disallowed goals (one against Bates, the other against Bowdoin) from finishing top of the table this year...  Top five were within four points of each other.  One or two bounces (or calls) and any of those top 5 could have finished first in the regular season.

I'd agree with Bucket and nescac1. Though I'm biased towards Wes, I'm a bit surprised at the number of selections this year given their position in the table and a first round loss in the NESCAC playoffs... and yet, they had multiple honorees across the teams. That's not to say the players aren't deserving... but should Williams not have more?

Another one that stuck out was the Co-Coaching Staff of the Year selections, awarded to Hamilton and Middlebury. I can see the argument for Hamilton - that's a team that finished at the bottom of the table last season, missing out on playoffs, who now goes into the NCAA Tournament as a top 10 team in the country with a NESCAC-semifinal loss in penalties to the reigning national champions. But, Middlebury? Don't get me wrong, it's hard to overlook their success in recent years, but that's precisely my point. Middlebury, a team usually at the top of the conference, lost in 90' in the NESCAC quarterfinals. Does this really make their staff deserving of this award? It feels like the committee just couldn't handle not giving something to Midd.

Finishing top of the table has to be worth something, no?

Seasonal awards are not awards for how a team does in post-season tournament.

CACtion

Predication for the games tomorrow. Cac a million - everyone else zero.
I for one have heard enough from the uneducated masses. Tomorrow they all learn, it's all about the 'Cac, and it always will be.

Sandon Mibut

Gonna be some chilly games this weekend! Few snow flakes currently flying on campus in Middlebury!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=868lAcCtSxo
* IDK jack about soccer. I cheer for Tufts, Middlebury and Upstate NY teams and I enjoy crunching numbers

SimpleCoach

Quote from: CACtion on November 13, 2026, 06:20:11 PMPredication for the games tomorrow. Cac a million - everyone else zero.
I for one have heard enough from the uneducated masses. Tomorrow they all learn, it's all about the 'Cac, and it always will be.

Good prediction ....

paclassic89

Except for Conn...

Sandon Mibut

7-1 NESCAC

23-6 GF:GA

I didn't see Conn but it looks like they had the upper hand.

Respect to a great senior class @ Conn with a tough ending.
* IDK jack about soccer. I cheer for Tufts, Middlebury and Upstate NY teams and I enjoy crunching numbers

stlawus

Conn most definitely did not have the upper hand, UMass Boston played them straight up and were solid defensively, they were well deserving of the win.

paclassic89

Impossible.  Conn is a NESCAC team so we'll just assume they dominated...

Cacfan1

UMass Boston defended their box very well, buried their chances, and came ready to play from the gun. Clearly, they scouted Conn and had a tailored game plan. Conn had its chances but got exposed as they are not strong on set pieces, lack a real vertical threat in transition, and don't really have goal poachers/hunters. Once Conn goes down, they struggle to break down 11 behind the ball as they approach the box (and what division 3 team wouldn't?). Tough ending for a powerful senior class. Burk's got his work cut out for him.

DagarmanSpartan

Ok, so my own alma mater, Case Western Reserve University, having punched its ticket to the Sweet 16, will be playing either Amherst or Messiah.

I'm hoping that it will be Amherst.
CWRU Grad, Class of 1994, big D3 sports fan of that school.  Also a fan of Yeshiva U at the D3 level.  Fan of Houston and Illinois at the D1-FBS level.

CACtion

Some thoughts from today. Surprised to see the number of goals conceded by teams in the NESCAC in the first round. That being said, still a dominant day for the conference. Conn's choke job is the obvious story of the day. Both players of the year and you bow out in the first round, truly rare display of fraudulence from the Camels.

In terms of tmr:
The matchups look quite difficult. That being said, I would be shocked if they didn't go 5-2 at the worst.
If the top players on nescac teams produce, others simply cannot keep up.
Players to watch tomorrow:
Wes: Saeed, they live and die by this guy. If he can produce at the same level post injury Wes could make a deep run.
Amherst: Shepherd, Underrated goalkeeper who has stepped up for the Mammoths constantly this year. They will need some big stops against perennial power Messiah.
Hamilton: Ferrare and Miller, Miller is the hottest player in the country. Ferrare has sparked the group since coming back a couple weeks ago.
Midd: Sawin and Dugan, probably the best 1-2 punch in the country. At their best they can single handedly win games.
Tufts: Bijan, Swiss Army knife player. They move him wherever they need him and he always produces. Babson will be exposed for the wannabes they are again tomorrow.
Williams: Labonski and Farmer, probably the top center back partnership in the conference. Doubt Hopkins will be able to break through those two.
Bowdoin: Banks, as he goes, the Polar Bears go. Runs the show in the middle of the park. Bowdoin will quietly end up in the final 4 this year.

nescac1

Seems like a third-place World Cup game broke out in Amherst, Amherst-Messiah tied 4-4 with ten minutes left, wild. 

NESCAC having a pretty tough time of it today overall, so far.  Williams-JHU and Hamilton-Denison currently tied; Midd and Tufts clinging to one-goal leads; Wesleyan down 1-0.