2026 D3 Men's Soccer National Perspective

Started by Gregory Sager, February 17, 2026, 01:52:12 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

D3SoccerTalker

Kudos to the Montclair State staff and assumingly those around him for potentially pushing this/giving him good advice. A lot of coaches might push for players like this to stay or give them weird advice on where to land next. Kid seems like he took some wise advice and found himself in a spot where he wanted to pursue a professional career which would be a bit more difficult to do staying at Montclair rather than Rutgers.

More often than not--kids in these situations end up taking more of an unrealistic/"ego" route and going to a place where they de facto end their soccer career early by just sitting the bench at some D1 school instead of sticking it out and continuing to crush it at their alma mater/former D3 institution. This has happened a lot in the past sadly, but Amer seems like he is on the right track and would be a great success story to see this kid turn this into a professional career! Best of luck!

Ejay

Quote from: D3SoccerTalker on November 20, 2026, 12:22:13 PMKudos to the Montclair State staff and assumingly those around him for potentially pushing this/giving him good advice. A lot of coaches might push for players like this to stay or give them weird advice on where to land next. Kid seems like he took some wise advice and found himself in a spot where he wanted to pursue a professional career which would be a bit more difficult to do staying at Montclair rather than Rutgers.

More often than not--kids in these situations end up taking more of an unrealistic/"ego" route and going to a place where they de facto end their soccer career early by just sitting the bench at some D1 school instead of sticking it out and continuing to crush it at their alma mater/former D3 institution. This has happened a lot in the past sadly, but Amer seems like he is on the right track and would be a great success story to see this kid turn this into a professional career! Best of luck!

If you recall, Lukovic was originally committed to Rutgers before landing at Montclair. Had a stellar 3 year career before missing his entire SR. year with an injury.  The move to Rutgers as a grad student was the logical next step. But yes, Coach Tumelty is a great guy and I'm sure he was happy to see Lukovic find success "at the next level".

camosfan

If he had any type of pro ambition he spent two years too much at Montclair, will be extremely difficult to match up to people his age who have been playing professionally for the last four years, maybe second division in like Greece, Ireland ; not sure about his prospects in a place like Portugal.

Kuiper

Quote from: camosfan on Yesterday at 10:11:10 AMIf he had any type of pro ambition he spent two years too much at Montclair, will be extremely difficult to match up to people his age who have been playing professionally for the last four years, maybe second division in like Greece, Ireland ; not sure about his prospects in a place like Portugal.

I'm pretty sure that describes the vast majority of DI players. Staying at Montclair puts him in no different spot with respect to higher-level European leagues than staying at Rutgers for 4 years.  They sometimes find themselves at a lower level European league, but those leagues are typically not much better than USL and they are often semi-pro (especially in Germany).  The best players these days are skipping college altogether.  Some still can go after playing MLS, but it's the exception, not the rule.

camosfan


SierraFD3soccer

Quote from: Kuiper on Yesterday at 10:18:46 AM
Quote from: camosfan on Yesterday at 10:11:10 AMIf he had any type of pro ambition he spent two years too much at Montclair, will be extremely difficult to match up to people his age who have been playing professionally for the last four years, maybe second division in like Greece, Ireland ; not sure about his prospects in a place like Portugal.

I'm pretty sure that describes the vast majority of DI players. Staying at Montclair puts him in no different spot with respect to higher-level European leagues than staying at Rutgers for 4 years.  They sometimes find themselves at a lower level European league, but those leagues are typically not much better than USL and they are often semi-pro (especially in Germany).  The best players these days are skipping college altogether.  Some still can go after playing MLS, but it's the exception, not the rule.

Absolutely true.

SimpleCoach

Quote from: Kuiper on Yesterday at 10:18:46 AM
Quote from: camosfan on Yesterday at 10:11:10 AMIf he had any type of pro ambition he spent two years too much at Montclair, will be extremely difficult to match up to people his age who have been playing professionally for the last four years, maybe second division in like Greece, Ireland ; not sure about his prospects in a place like Portugal.

I'm pretty sure that describes the vast majority of DI players. Staying at Montclair puts him in no different spot with respect to higher-level European leagues than staying at Rutgers for 4 years.  They sometimes find themselves at a lower level European league, but those leagues are typically not much better than USL and they are often semi-pro (especially in Germany).  The best players these days are skipping college altogether.  Some still can go after playing MLS, but it's the exception, not the rule.

I think the reality of the modern game is that if you are not able to get to Europe when you are 16ish (must have dual citizenship) or at least 18, the road to becoming a sustainable professional soccer player is tenuous.  Be that here in the US or elsewhere.

SC.